What PPS is proposing#
"Rightsizing" is PPS's term for closing and consolidating schools, along with changing attendance boundaries and moving programs, in response to declining enrollment. PPS rightsizing page
In early October 2026, PPS released two scenarios plus a status-quo option. Scenario A closes 14 schools; Scenario B closes 11. PPS scenarios Irvington Elementary closes under both A and B. Grant–McDaniel regional summary Under Scenario A, the district's regional breakdown splits Irvington's students three ways: elementary students to Beverly Cleary, middle-graders to Beaumont Middle School, and high-schoolers to Grant, with Beverly Cleary's attendance boundary expanding to take in the Irvington neighborhood. PPS rightsizing dashboard
In October, the superintendent said she was "leaning into" Scenario B, which she said still puts "70% of our students or above in schools that are sustainable" (PPS's own summary says 73%). OPB, Oct 16 · PPS: district-wide scenarios Her final recommendation came out on November 12: 10 elementary schools close over two years (see "The final recommendation, checked").
The number has grown over the year, from "5 to 10" schools last spring to "up to 20" by late summer. KGW · OPB
The process runs in phases, ending in a final board vote scheduled for December 15, 2026: PPS timeline · OPB
- Exploration (Fall 2025–Winter 2026)
- Plan and form advisory committee (Winter 2025–26)
- Develop and share scenarios (Spring–Fall 2026)
- Superintendent's recommendation (Fall 2026)
- Board vote (December 2026)
- Changes take effect (Fall 2027)
The final recommendation, checked against PPS's own numbersNew#
On November 12, Superintendent Armstrong recommended closing 10 elementary schools over two years. Beach, Buckman, Creston, Irvington, Peninsula, and Sabin would close in fall 2027; Lewis, Marysville, Rose City Park, and Woodmere in fall 2028. The board votes December 15. PPS: Superintendent's recommendation, Nov 12 PPS's own packet makes the case against it.
- Closing schools doesn't save school jobs. PPS's own staffing model meets its target for school-staff cuts without closing a single school. With the closures, the model cuts 31 more school positions before some are added back, and PPS hasn't published the net. Gov. Tina Kotek said PPS must "cut administrative costs and other things before they talk about closing schools." The board votes on closures December 15; PPS's budget recommendations, central-office cuts included, aren't due until January 12.
- The savings are small, and they don't go to the deficit. The superintendent's memo said $7.1 million would be left "to reinvest." On November 17, four days after releasing the memo and the day the superintendent presented it to the board, PPS corrected its savings table to $5.65 million, 20% less. The memo's summary still says $7.1 million. The memo also prices 31 new bus routes at $2.7 million a year that the table doesn't appear to count. Either way, it's 4.5% to 8.7% of the $65 million gap.
- Most of the deficit is pensions, in the board's own words. Its 2027 legislative agenda says two-thirds of the gap comes from rising pension costs and asks the state for $500 million to cover them.
- The plan breaks its own rules. It closes Rose City Park, which PPS projects above its own size line, and keeps open smaller schools it promises to "monitor." On the west side, 8 of 10 elementary schools are projected under the line, and none closes. Seven of the 10 closing buildings are bigger than the schools taking their students. And it closes Marysville two years after a $2.5 million state seismic grant that requires it to stay a school until 2036.
- The equity statement argues against the plan. It says multilingual learners carry "more of this change than any other group" and the west side closes nothing. Without funded commitments, it calls the result "an enrollment plan with an equity result." The commitments aren't funded.
In fairness, PPS says that without closures, its cuts spread across 81 buildings mean more combined-grade classes, specialists split between schools, and principals on lunch duty. That's a real cost. But it's an argument for protecting school staff and funding schools, not for closing them: PPS's own model reaches its staffing target without closing a building.
Why PPS says it's necessary#
The enrollment problem is real. PPS has lost about 6,086 students since 2018-19 and expects to lose roughly 3,400 more by 2031-32. K-12 Dive The district's case is that, without changes, most schools fall below its size lines (360 students for an elementary school, 500 for a middle or K-8 school) and become too small to staff well. By its count, if nothing changes, only 48% of students would attend a "sustainable" school in 2031-32, against 73–80% under the two scenarios. PPS: district-wide scenarios
But those lines aren't a finding about Portland schools. They are the "prototype school" sizes from Oregon's Quality Education Model, a state tool for estimating what an adequately funded school costs, not a test of when a school is failing; nothing in it says a 300-student school should close. Oregon QEM issue brief (LPRO, 2023) And the district's own dashboard shows who absorbs the moves: Scenario A reassigns 27% of K-8 students, and students receiving multilingual services are moved at a higher rate (31%) than any other group. PPS rightsizing dashboard
And the plan doesn't hold every school to those lines. Under Scenario A, 11 of the 39 elementary schools left open would still be under 360 students in 2031-32, some smaller than schools it closes, and Jackson Middle drops from 515 to 405, below the 500 line, because of the plan. PPS rightsizing dashboard
The enrollment forecast: solid for the district, shaky school by school#
Every closure call rests on Portland State's projection of each school's enrollment in 2031-32, and the superintendent says the district doesn't "question those numbers." OPB: Think Out Loud, Oct 16 For the district as a whole, the forecast has earned that trust: its one-year total has missed by a median of about 0.5%. PSU forecast, Table 4.4 School by school, it hasn't. We checked about 4,200 of Portland State's past school forecasts against what schools actually enrolled. In normal years, a forecast six years out (the distance PPS is deciding at) missed by about 10%, and more than one school in five missed by over 20%. PSU forecast archive Sixteen schools sit within 10% of a size line in 2031-32, so their "sustainable" label falls inside the forecast's ordinary error, and Portland State publishes no school-level error range. PSU forecast, Table 5.5
Irvington shows how the misses run: Portland State has under-forecast it three years in a row while enrollment grew from 228 to 259, and its newest forecast again has the school shrinking. In fairness, even a much better forecast wouldn't lift Irvington over 360. The point is about how PPS is deciding, not about any one school.
Why families leave: PPS asked, and didn't say#
Since the pandemic, most of the decline is simply fewer children. The bigger loss of families choosing PPS came earlier: the district enrolled 82% of school-age children in its boundaries in 2015 and 74% by 2019, and has won back only a sliver since. PSU forecast, Sec. 1.2 One destination PPS does count is growing: 1,118 students who live in its boundaries now attend virtual charter schools run by other districts, up about 9% since the end of last school year, while PPS's own enrollment fell 2.7%. PPS Enrollment and Transfer Center, Nov 2026
PPS paid to find out why families leave, and hasn't published the answer. Its 2025 study by Symbol LLC reached the board in January 2026 and surfaced only through a parent's public-records request. Symbol LLC for PPS: Summary Report, Jan 2026 Families who left cited academic quality and safety; 60% of current families said they had considered leaving, most often over academics and class size; and 75% said they chose their school for its neighborhood, which is exactly what a closure takes away. In fairness, the survey drew volunteers, and Symbol says its results can't be generalized to all families. But they match PPS's own earlier research, and the survey's questions about redistricting, asked of every group, have no published results.
PPS's own projections assume no family leaves. Its dashboard moves 100% of neighborhood students to their new schools, so both scenarios project at least as many students as doing nothing, though the superintendent says losses were built in. PPS rightsizing dashboard This fall, enrollment at the 14 schools Scenario A would close fell twice as fast as across PPS's K-8 schools (5.4% vs 2.6%). PPS: October 1 enrollment, 2026-27
What the superintendent told Irvington families on October 15 — and what the record shows#
At Irvington on October 15, Superintendent Armstrong told families that consolidation would put 80% of students in schools that are "stable and resourced well." That 80% counts students in schools above the size line, not resources. On the radio the next day she said "well resourced" means "getting to a size of 360," OPB: Think Out Loud, Oct 16 while PPS's own deck says a larger school "does not automatically get a full-time librarian, certain staff, or specific programs." PPS: Sept 1 board deck
She also said money "captured from closures and consolidations will be reinvested back into schools." Five days later she estimated those savings at $11–14 million, "planning estimates" PPS hasn't backed with any published analysis, against a $65 million cut happening regardless. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting And she would not put a class-size cap in writing, saying the staffing plan will come with her November recommendation. OPB: Think Out Loud, Oct 16 None of this requires assuming bad faith: on resources and savings, the spoken reassurances simply claim more than the district's written documents do.
Full analysis: What the superintendent told Irvington families →
What it means for teachers and staff#
Calling a closure a "merger" doesn't change who keeps a job. Under the teachers' contract, the receiving school's teachers keep their positions, and the closing school's teachers compete for whatever is left by seniority; "usually there are not enough positions." PAT contract, Art. 18.6.9 The contract treats closures, mergers, and reconfigurations as the same event. Being left without an assignment isn't automatically a layoff, since teachers are routed to other openings first, but it means losing your school community. The last consolidation shows the cost: in its first year, 39% of staff of color at the affected schools left them, against 21% at other schools. PPS: SEGC Equity Audit
What the research and other cities show#
After decades of closures across the country, there's no reliable evidence they deliver what districts promise. They rarely save much: a 2026 Stanford study found California districts that closed schools were no more likely to escape financial distress. Stanford News Students gain only when they land in a clearly better school, and fewer than half do. CREDO (2017) The documented successes, like New York's phase-out of failing high schools, sent students somewhere markedly better. PPS hasn't shown that its receiving schools are any stronger than the ones closing.
In Portland, even PPS's own estimate of the savings ($11–14 million), which it hasn't backed up, would cover only a sixth to a fifth of its $65 million gap, PPS: Oct 20 board meeting and its own family guides concede a larger school "does not automatically get a full-time librarian, certain staff, or specific programs." PPS family guides The burden lands unevenly: Southeast and North Portland lose 10 of the 14 schools under Scenario A, and nearly every dual-language program being moved serves immigrant and multilingual families there. Cleveland–Franklin · Jefferson–Roosevelt
Where students land: the schools that would receive them#
The research is clear that closures help students only when they land in a clearly better school. So we checked where Portland's displaced students would land, using the state's own 2025-26 test results for every closing school and the school receiving its students. ODE: Assessment Group Reports It's a coin flip. In reading, 8 of the 14 closing schools send their students to a higher-scoring school and 6 to a lower-scoring one; in math it's close to the reverse. The biggest drops land on the students the plan says it most wants to help: Peninsula's students go from a school where 44% read at grade level to Rosa Parks, at 15%, and Beach's and James John's Spanish-immersion students move to César Chávez, at 20%. Students with disabilities land in lower-scoring settings in about half the cases where the state reports their results (4 of 9 in reading, 5 of 9 in math), and the drops are steep. And the plan closes three of PPS's eight "Inclusive School Communities," the model PPS built to teach students with disabilities in their neighborhood school, which its own progress report says is improving their attendance and early reading. PPS: Inclusive Schools Progress Report 2025-26
In fairness, a school's average mostly reflects who attends it, and for students in poverty some gaps narrow or reverse: at King, they outscore their peers at Sabin. And spending per student follows the receiving school: it is higher at high-poverty schools like Rosa Parks and lower at large schools like Beverly Cleary, so closing a building doesn't by itself add money per student.
The equity case for closures, checked against the data#
The strongest case for the plan came from Director Rashelle Chase-Miller and Vice Chair Michelle DePass on October 20: the district is failing Black and brown students, North and outer Southeast Portland are "always on the menu," and "kids in North Portland cannot wait." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting They're right about the problem. The plan doesn't fix it. The number that alarmed them counts students in buildings above a size line, and it rises automatically when a small school closes, whether or not any child learns more. On test results, half the closing schools send students to a lower-scoring school, and at King and Rosa Parks, which would take Sabin's and Peninsula's students, Black students score below the district's Black-student average. Brentwood, a Title I middle school where nearly half the students are from historically underserved groups, would lose its Title I status. And North Portland moves a third of its students under either scenario, more than any other region. The pairings themselves follow building space, not equity: some send students into whiter, wealthier schools, while others concentrate poverty.
In fairness, doing nothing also costs: PPS says the $65 million gap would cut about 223 school positions under the status quo, and that closures could preserve about 97 of them. That is the plan's best argument. But those are "planning estimates, not … guaranteed reinvestments," shown once and not yet backed by any published analysis, and nothing in them is aimed at the schools and students the equity case is about.
The districts PPS chose as models#
PPS named San Antonio, Seattle, and Denver as the models for its process, and never told the board how they turned out. PPS Board of Education meetings (March 31, 2026 work session) Seattle cut its list from 21 schools to 4 as projected savings shrank to about $5.5 million against a deficit near $100 million, then canceled the plan. KUOW Denver's $29.9 million in "savings" was mostly per-pupil money that followed students to their new schools, leaving $6.6 million to reinvest. DPS recommendation package, p. 28 San Antonio closed 15 schools; a week into the next year, one in five affected students hadn't shown up, and it is closing more. TPR Its equity auditors, the same team PPS later hired, warned before that vote that past closures had hurt attendance and grades. SAISD equity audit (Nov 2023)
In fairness, about half of Denver's displaced students chose higher-rated schools, helped by guaranteed priority and busing that PPS's scenarios don't offer. Chalkbeat
PPS's own audit of the last consolidation: students held steady, trust didn't#
PPS hired independent researchers to review its last enrollment-balancing effort, the Southeast Guiding Coalition of 2020–23, and posted what they found. PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation For students, the news is mostly reassuring: students at the affected schools did about as well as similar students elsewhere, with small reading gains for several groups, including multilingual learners and dual-language students. But middle schoolers, whose access to a full middle school was the point of the changes, showed no gains. The process did lasting damage: only 3% of staff trust the district to handle rightsizing fairly, 39% of staff of color left the affected schools in the first year, and at one school converted to dual-language, Black students were almost entirely displaced. The auditors told PPS that before using "well-resourced" to justify closures, it should show that students will actually get more stable staffing and stronger supports, not just enrollment numbers that improve "on paper." That is still to come, for a plan about four times the size.
What PPS has, and hasn't, made public#
PPS has released a lot: a family guide for each of its 81 schools, and a dashboard with projected enrollment, building use, and who would move. PPS rightsizing dashboard That's real progress. But six things anyone would need to check the plan are still missing:
- the seat counts behind each building's capacity (staff say the model will be posted), PPS: Oct 20 board meeting
- the method and margin of error behind the school-by-school projections,
- how many families PPS expects to lose when schools close (its projections assume none),
- what would happen to each closed building,
- the district's own research on why families leave, including its results on redistricting, and
- any definition of success, or a commitment to an independent review one and three years out.
PPS's own communications playbook: what leaders are told to say#
In May 2026, PPS's chief of communications at the time, Candice Grose, wrote a rightsizing communications plan and a 49-page playbook of talking points for central office leaders, board members, principals, and parent advocates. She has since left for Memphis-Shelby County Schools and posted both on her portfolio site; the files are titled "FINAL." Her copies have since gone offline, so the links here go to copies saved for this guide. PPS Rightsizing Communications Plan · PPS Rightsizing Communications Playbook Much of it is ordinary, even sound, practice. But the plan's goal for this fall is to move the public from asking "Why are we doing this?" to asking "How were these recommendations developed?" It lists "political organizing/opposition" as a risk to manage, and it measures success by web traffic, media sentiment, and meeting attendance, not by whether anything families said changed a recommendation.
The board members who vote on December 15 get the same message as staff, down to a stock answer for when they're asked to pick a side. One of their scripted lines concedes that "even after rightsizing, the district will still face a structural deficit." And neither document mentions Salem, the state school fund, or the state's reserve fund, the money a pause would wait for.
The national network our superintendent belongs to#
This is context, not the core argument. Superintendent Armstrong belongs to Chiefs for Change, a national network of school leaders that grew out of Jeb Bush's education foundation and is funded by Walton, Bloomberg, Chan Zuckerberg, and others; its platform has long favored charter schools and school choice. Chiefs for Change · K-12 Dive · InfluenceWatch None of that shows anyone ordered Portland to close schools, and the network describes itself as bipartisan. It helps explain why Portland's plan looks so much like other cities'.
The pattern: closures in other districts#
Of the 37 Chiefs for Change members who lead a school district, 22 have closed or formally proposed closing schools during their tenure, and we found none that has published an independent evaluation showing its closures worked. In fairness, the network draws from big urban districts, where enrollment is falling fastest. And one fear doesn't apply here: Oregon has no law handing closed buildings to charter schools. But PPS gives the city, county, and state no right of first refusal either, so what happens to a closed building is up to the board. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting
The same script, city to city#
The words repeat, too. "Right-size," "sustainable," "small schools cost more," "stability," and "doing nothing is not an option" show up nearly verbatim in Portland, Cleveland, Indianapolis, Boston, and Philadelphia. In fairness, some of it is ordinary school-administration vocabulary. But PPS also hands its parent representatives a "This, Not That!" messaging guide, while the charter of that same parent body says it is no substitute for testifying to the board. PPS Village Table page · Representative toolkit
Done to North Portland, in the name of improvement#
North Portland has been reorganized "for its own good" before, and each time its families paid for it. In the 1970s, desegregation meant busing Black children out of their neighborhoods and closing their middle grades. Willamette Week A transfer policy meant to integrate schools ended up draining them. LSE US Centre And in the mid-2000s, PPS answered falling enrollment and tight budgets by merging schools into K-8s, mostly in North and Northeast Portland and other lower-income areas, while wealthier neighborhoods kept their middle schools. Its own superintendent later said it was done "too quickly without planning," and it took more than a decade to undo. Willamette Week (2015) Each change was sold as an improvement. Doing something is not the same as doing something that works.
Portland has stopped closures before#
This board has been made to back down before, and the playbook is on the record. In 1982, after the board voted 5–2 to break a promise and close the last elementary school in Portland's Black community, the Black United Front shut down board meetings, kept students home, and picketed the director who moved the plan. Within ten weeks, after federal mediation, the board reversed itself 6–1. Public History PDX In 2013, families in North Portland's Jefferson cluster, where PPS had closed more schools in a decade than in every other cluster combined, refused to be split by race and class, and the superintendent's revised plan closed no neighborhood school. The Indypendent Oakland reversed its closures in 2023 after voters changed the board. EdSource And when the money ran short, Portland raised it: a county income tax in 2003, and in 2019 a teacher walkout that helped pass $1 billion a year for schools.
The wins share four things: a coalition too broad to split, pressure that made business as usual impossible, consequences at the ballot box, and a way for the board to back down. In fairness, not every fight was won: PPS closed Marshall High in 2011 anyway.
What we're asking for#
The enrollment decline is real. The $65 million gap is real. Neither one is fixed by closing schools: the only savings figure PPS has offered, an estimate the superintendent presented once and hasn't backed up, is $11–14 million, a sixth to a fifth of the gap, and PPS hasn't said whether that recurs (see "What the research and other cities show"). The problem is in Salem, and that's where the fight belongs.
A pause is not the status quo. PPS presents its choice as Scenario A, Scenario B, or the "status quo," PPS scenarios as if anyone opposing closures is defending things as they are. Nobody here is. Families, educators, and the board agree the current system is failing too many students, and that the money to fix it has to come from the state. A pause buys time to pull every other lever first. In Portland: a staffing plan the public can check, and budget choices that protect students first, like the $13.2 million for school-based staff Director Stephanie Engelsman tried to restore in June. Willamette Week In Salem: the reserve fund and the 2027 budget. Debating how many schools to close, 14, 11, or six, accepts the premise that closing schools is the answer. It isn't. That's an invitation as much as a demand: the board has already asked Salem for the same money we're fighting for, even though PPS's own communications playbook never mentions the state (see "PPS's own communications playbook"). Stand with families in Salem, rather than closing neighborhood schools to cover for the state.
Here is what we're asking for, in order.
1. Now: pause the vote. The board should postpone any closure vote until after the 2027 Legislature sets the state school budget. That isn't a stalling tactic; it's the district's own logic. The superintendent says the staffing and class-size numbers can't be firm until the state sets its school fund, OPB: Think Out Loud, Oct 16 the board's own chair has called the deficit "an emergency" that the state's reserve fund exists to prevent, KPTV and the state's Quality Education Commission has told lawmakers schools need billions more, setting up the 2027 session's biggest fight. KATU A closed school doesn't reopen when the money arrives. Make the irreversible decision after Salem answers, not before. Gov. Tina Kotek has said much the same. In an October 13 letter to the superintendent and board chair, she stopped short of asking PPS to withdraw its plans but wrote that "taking the time to get this right is not a delay in making difficult decisions." OPB, Oct 14
What a pause means, and what it costs. A pause isn't open-ended. The Oregon Constitution limits the Legislature's 2027 session to 160 days; the last such session ran from January 17 to June 25. Oregon Legislature: 2023 Oregon Laws, foreword We're asking the board to decide by fall 2027, once two things have happened: the Legislature has set the 2027-29 state school budget, and PPS has published what this guide shows is still missing: the staffing plan, how many families it expects to lose, the seat counts behind building capacity, a plan for each building it would close, and a savings analysis that shows its work (see "What PPS has, and hasn't, made public"). Deciding then has a cost, and we should say so plainly: no closure could take effect before fall 2028, a year later than PPS plans. By PPS's own estimate, which it hasn't backed up, closing schools in 2027 would spare the equivalent of about 76 to 97 school positions from the 2027-28 cuts. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting That estimate is as unproven when it argues for speed as when it argues for savings, and the $65 million in cuts arrives in 2027-28 either way. So the year should come with protection for the schools that can least afford it: the board should publish where the 2027-28 cuts would fall, school by school, and keep them from landing disproportionately on Title I schools.
2. Next: release the Education Stability Fund. Oregon holds about $1 billion in its school rainy-day fund, last tapped for $400 million in 2019-21. OPB It can be released when revenue falls short or when the governor declares an emergency. Willamette Week PPS, its board, its teachers' union, and the state school boards association have all asked for it. KATU · OSBA The board and the families fighting this plan agree on this. Use that: ask every candidate for governor and the Legislature, before and after the November 3 election, whether they will release it.
3. Lasting: fund schools properly, and change how Oregon pays for them. As PPS's student board representative told lawmakers this year, the state has not once fully funded its own Quality Education Model, the same model PPS borrowed its 360- and 500-student lines from. KATU Closing buildings to fit an underfunded budget only locks the underfunding in. The 2019 walkout shows organized families and educators can move new revenue through Salem in a single session.
Part of that fix doesn't need new money: hold virtual schools to the same standards as every other public school, and pay them closer to what they cost to run. Oregon's virtual charters draw state school funding per student while running with no buildings, no buses, and far larger classes, and a 2017 Secretary of State audit made 15 recommendations for overseeing them, none of which the Department of Education had fully carried out by the follow-up a year later. A former education adviser to two governors says the state board or the governor could act by administrative rule or executive action, without waiting for the Legislature. Willamette Week / Oregon Journalism Project, Nov 3 That would leave more of the State School Fund for every other school, Portland's included. Today, 1,118 students who live in PPS's boundaries attend a virtual charter run by another district (see "Why families leave"). PPS has made this argument before: in 2015, its government-relations office backed a bill to move oversight of large virtual charters from local districts to the state. PPS Government Relations: HB 3151 testimony (2015)
How we get there:
- One demand, citywide. No school's survival should be bought with another's. We reject any version of this plan that trades Irvington for Peninsula or Southeast for North. The 2013 organizers won by refusing that split; so can we (see "The equity case, checked").
- Every vote on the record. Four of the seven board seats are on the ballot in May 2027, Ballotpedia and at least one director has said she won't run again. Willamette Week Whether or not a director runs again, a vote to close 11 to 14 schools before the state has answered will be the defining vote of their public life. Families will remember it, and so will every future ballot it appears next to. That's how Oakland's reversal happened.
- Show up, in numbers. Testify at the November 18, November 19, and December 1 listening sessions, and fill the room on November 17 and December 15 (see "Key dates"). Then take the same message to Salem in January.
Questions worth asking#
Whether you're a parent, a neighbor, or a board member weighing this, these questions hold up regardless of where you start:
- Transparency: Will PPS release the raw capacity and utilization numbers and the projection method behind the family guides (the part the recommendations actually rest on) before the December 15 vote?
- Forecast uncertainty: Portland State's school-level forecasts have typically missed by about 10% six years out, and 16 schools sit within 10% of the size lines in 2031-32. Will PPS publish a range for each school's projection, and show which closure decisions would change within it?
- Families who leave: The dashboard assumes every neighborhood student follows their school. What loss did PPS actually model, as the superintendent says it did, and will it publish the percentages before the vote?
- Class size, in writing: Will the staffing plan promised for early November state the class sizes and staffing ratios at each receiving school, and will the district commit to a class-size cap before the board votes?
- Why families leave: Will PPS publish its full January 2026 family survey, including the redistricting questions, and explain how the plan responds to the reasons families gave for leaving?
- Students with disabilities: The special-education parent group SEPTSA has asked PPS for a school-by-school analysis of how each scenario affects students with disabilities, including whether each receiving school has the rooms and staff to serve them, and for a public presentation of it at least a week before the vote. Will PPS provide both? SEPTSA: Special Education Impacts and Information Requests
- Accountability: Will the district commit to an independent evaluation at one and three years, so we'll actually know whether the closures delivered for students and for the budget?
- Lessons from the models: PPS studied San Antonio, Seattle, and Denver as models for this process. Did staff review what happened in those districts after their closure decisions, and if so, why weren't the results presented to the board?
- Savings, net: Will PPS publish what Denver did: the gross savings, how much of that simply follows students to their new schools, and the net amount actually left to "reinvest"?
- Where the cuts land: Where would the 2027-28 cuts to schools fall, school by school, with closures and without, and how many at Title I schools?
- What changed? PPS's communications plan measures success by web traffic, sentiment, and attendance. What in the superintendent's recommendation changed because of what families said, and will PPS show it, school by school?
- Board talking points: PPS's communications plan lists "Board talking points" among its first deliverables. Have directors received district-written talking points on rightsizing, and will PPS publish them?
- How much is ours? How much of this plan originated in Portland, versus the national model this superintendent trained in through Chiefs for Change?
- Equity in practice: Why do North and Southeast Portland, and the dual-language programs serving multilingual families, carry most of the closures and program break-ups, while the west side loses far fewer?
Key dates & how to get involved#
- Oct 15 (Thu): "Sip and Spill" with Superintendent Armstrong at Irvington (after morning arrival). A chance to ask questions directly.
- Oct 17–29: Board "Community Connections" on rightsizing around the district (McDaniel, Lincoln, Cleveland/Marshall campus, and virtual). PPS rightsize calendar
- Nov 18, Nov 19 & Dec 1: Board of Education Public Listening Sessions: formal testimony before the vote. Sign up to speak at publiccomment@pps.net.
- Nov 4: Board meeting where the district reports what it heard in community engagement.
- Nov 17: Superintendent's final recommendation, with the staffing plan. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting
- December 15, 2026: Board's scheduled final vote on the scenarios, per district staff on October 20. (Some directors and The Oregonian have cited December 17; check the board calendar before planning around it.)
- Fall 2027: Changes take effect if approved.
Give feedback: PPS has a rightsizing scenario survey linked from its scenarios page. Public comment sign-up for board meetings goes through the PPS Board page.
Connect with others: Rank-and-file Educators for Democracy (RED) and Labor Notes educators are already organizing against rightsizing, and the Portland Association of Teachers has opposed the closures. You don't have to start from scratch.
The bottom line: the vote isn't until December 15, the numbers behind the plan still aren't fully public, the teachers' union opposes the plan, and Portland has reversed closures before. Showing up, in numbers, at the listening sessions, and in writing, is how that happens again.
Closure tally — Chiefs for Change district leaders#
The district-by-district list behind "22 of 37": every Chiefs for Change member who leads a school district, what each has done about closures, and a source for each.