← PPS Rightsizing Guide

Full analysis

The national playbook

NewAdded November 17: The superintendent's final recommendation, checked against PPS's own packet: a staffing target met without closures, savings PPS has already cut by 20% in a revised memo, a state seismic grant at risk at Marysville, and a size rule the west side doesn't follow


Contents

The national network our superintendent belongs to#

Everything else in this guide stands on its own; this section adds context that helps explain the pattern rather than resting the case on it. Portland is following a national model, not setting one. The same move — closing and consolidating schools on enrollment and "sustainability" grounds — is being made city after city by superintendents who trained in and belong to the same national network, funded by the same handful of foundations. That doesn't take a conspiracy; it's what happens when a shared playbook and shared funders meet similar conditions. The fair question for the board is how much of this plan is Portland's own, and how much arrived from the national model.

Portland's plan isn't happening in isolation. Superintendent Kimberlee Armstrong belongs to Chiefs for Change, a national network of district and state education leaders, and completed its "Future Chiefs" leadership program before coming to PPS. Chiefs for Change

The network was founded by former Republican governor Jeb Bush's education foundation, became an independent nonprofit in 2015, and in its earlier years advocated for charter schools and Common Core. K-12 Dive It has around 44 member leaders, mostly big-city superintendents, and is now led by CEO Robert Runcie. Chiefs for Change network

A concrete example of that advocacy: in 2014, Chiefs for Change sent Congress a letter supporting the Success and Opportunity Through Quality Charter Schools Act (H.R. 10), federal legislation to expand charter schools. The letter is on the congressional record. The letter (House Education & Workforce Committee) · About H.R. 10 And that advocacy didn't end when the network went independent: in 2017, its CEO, Mike Magee, named "real access to excellent public school choices" the first of five principles in the group's shared vision. The 74

Taken together, the network's platform has been consistent over time: more charter and virtual schools, broader school choice, and judging schools largely by standardized-test results, including A–F school grades. EdWeek (2010) · the network's own vision (2017)

Its major funders are national philanthropies: Blue Meridian Partners (about $47.6M since 2020), the Bloomberg Family Foundation, the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative, and the Walton Family Foundation. InfluenceWatch

Put the pieces together and a throughline emerges, the one many education researchers and parent groups point to. The foundations funding this network also bankroll charter schools and "school choice." The method treats a school district like a balance sheet: enrollment thresholds, standardized metrics, and consultant-built scenarios decide which neighborhood schools survive, with communities consulted late and narrowly. And closed public buildings often end up with privately run charters, explicitly so in states like Ohio (see the next section). Critics describe the sum as a slow shift of public education toward private management and technocratic, top-down governance. Portland isn't Ohio (the next section explains why), but it is being run through the same framework by a superintendent trained in the same network.

One fair caveat: Chiefs for Change describes itself as bipartisan, and many members lead Democratic-leaning city districts. What actually ties Portland to the pattern isn't a years-old policy letter but the current record: Portland's own superintendent as a sitting member, shared funders, a shared training pipeline, and a strikingly similar approach showing up city to city, which is the next section.

Further reading on the national-playbook pattern: Armstrong also launched a PPS pilot with Colin Kaepernick's AI company, Lumi, which the board later paused, an example of the public-private AI partnerships Chiefs for Change promotes. OPB

The pattern: closures in other districts#

We went further than a sample. We checked all 37 Chiefs for Change members who run an individual school district: 22 have closed or formally proposed closing or consolidating schools during their tenure, 12 show no such action (several are growing districts building new schools), and 3 more have consolidation studies underway. The full sourced list, every district, leader, status, and link, is in the Closure tally tab. And for all that closing, not one of them can show it worked — across this entire network, we could not find a single district that has published an independent evaluation finding its closures actually delivered, for students or for the budget. A few of the clearest cases:

District Leader (Chiefs for Change) What happened Source
Cleveland Warren Morgan Consolidation plan; ~18 buildings to be emptied Ideastream
Philadelphia Tony Watlington ~20 proposed, 17 approved for closure by 2027 WHYY
Atlanta Bryan Johnson 16 schools to close/repurpose; reported to hit Black communities hardest Atlanta News First
Detroit Nikolai Vitti Several small schools closing Chalkbeat
Indianapolis Aleesia Johnson "Rebuilding Stronger" closures/mergers (2023) Chalkbeat
Chicago (2013) historical cautionary case 50 schools closed in one year under mayoral control NBC Chicago

Important context, in fairness: the network recruits mostly from large urban districts, which are exactly where enrollment is falling fastest. So the pattern reflects shared conditions and a shared playbook as much as any central direction. What's striking is how similar the rationale and rollout look across these districts, and that this superintendent trained inside that network before bringing the same approach here.

The same script, city to city#

It isn't only the same action; it's often the same words. Here is how PPS describes its plan, next to how other Chiefs for Change districts described theirs. The vocabulary, and sometimes the exact framing, recurs. The repeated word is italicized throughout (emphasis added):

"Right-size": the word reframes closing a school as correcting a sizing error, not cutting a service a neighborhood depends on.

  • Portland: calls the whole effort "rightsizing."
  • Cleveland: "takes bold action to right-size, stabilize, and secure a brighter future for CMSD scholars."
  • Jackson: Superintendent Errick Greene's plan: "optimization or right-sizing […] a way of ensuring that we have the optimal resources." Mississippi Free Press

"Sustainable":

  • Portland: "the sustainable use of our school facilities," a system "that is sustainable over time."
  • Cleveland: "a sustainable future for students."
  • Indianapolis: "financial sustainability over time."
  • Boston: "long-term sustainability of BPS."

"Small schools cost more": this is the premise the whole plan rests on — and it isn't Portland's. It's the exact claim of its paid consultant, ERS (see "Where the script comes from").

  • Portland: "Staff and supports spread both unevenly and thin" (its own Sept 1 board deck). As Dr. Armstrong put it, "we're closing schools because we're spreading our resources too thin."
  • Indianapolis: "small, underutilized schools — which cost more, and leave limited dollars for enrichments."
  • Boston: "district resources stretched too thin across too many school communities."

"Stability": the reassurance promises the opposite of what a closure delivers — the disruption of losing your school.

  • Portland: "strengthening stability" and a plan "without requiring students and families to navigate repeated disruptions throughout their K-12 experience."
  • Cleveland: "fewer moves and more stability."

"Equity and access":

  • Portland: "strengthening stability, equity, and access," so that "every student has access to a high-quality education."
  • Cleveland: "more equitable access to strong programs while reducing the district's budget deficit."
  • Indianapolis: "excellent, more equitable choices for learning."

"Hard but necessary decisions":

  • Portland: "The question that I hold onto, though, is what happens if we do nothing?" — Supt. Kimberlee Armstrong.
  • Cleveland: "tough but necessary decisions."
  • Indianapolis: "Doing nothing is not an option — we will go into the red," under the banner "We can do hard things together."
  • Philadelphia: "some of the decisions we have to make will be difficult."

In fairness, some of this is simply the shared vocabulary of school administration, and declining enrollment is a real pressure in all of these cities. But the consistency is the point: the same brand word ("right-size"), the same rationale ("small schools cost more"), the same reassurances ("stability," "fewer disruptions," "equitable access"), surfacing city after city among leaders from the same network. That is what a shared playbook sounds like, and it is exactly what the "we studied this carefully, just for Portland" framing is meant to obscure.

And the script reaches all the way down to Portland's own talking points. You don't have to infer the messaging discipline. The district wrote it down. PPS's Office of Family & Community Engagement convenes a "Village Table" of parent representatives, which it calls "our new districtwide Site Council" and "a space designed to model what inclusive, authentic family input looks like at the central office level." It equips them with a Representative Toolkit of "suggested talking points" and a "This, Not That!" messaging guide. The talking points carry the familiar vocabulary: "well-resourced schools," "greater stability," "more sustainable school sizes." And the district's own September presentation frames the goal as "one standard of opportunity and support" and "opportunity that never depends on your address," an almost exact echo of Chiefs for Change's stated vision of strong schools "regardless of where [students] live or their family's income." PPS Village Table page · Representative toolkit · September presentation

The "This, Not That!" guide is the tell. It coaches parent representatives to replace "PPS is closing 10–15 schools" with "examples of the magnitude of change that may be necessary," and, when a parent says "The district does not care about what I have to say!", to point them to "several engagements throughout September" and a staff liaison rather than engage the complaint. The Village Table's own charter, meanwhile, states it "does not make district decisions" and "does not serve as a substitute for public comment or Board testimony". So here is why this matters for families: the body PPS built to showcase family voice is, by its own terms, not the channel that reaches the Board on the record. The talking points families are handed are the same ones traveling city to city, and the venue handed to them to raise concerns is one the district has defined as non-binding. If you want your objection to count before the December 15 vote, the Village Table isn't the place; Board testimony is. The district-level version of this toolkit, a 49-page playbook of scripts for leaders, board members, principals, and parent advocates, is now public too (see "PPS's own communications playbook").

Where the script comes from: a shared, funded infrastructure#

The advisor behind the "small schools cost more" argument. Education Resource Strategies (ERS) is a national nonprofit consultancy whose core message to districts is that small schools are financially unsustainable: "small schools cost 20-30% more to operate on a per-pupil basis," and leaders should "balance school consolidation with the optimization of small schools" to reach "more sustainable schooling models." ERS That is, nearly word for word, PPS's own rationale. And Portland is an ERS client: through a competitive process (Request for Proposals 2022-002), the PPS board approved a contract with ERS to "develop a strategic resource analysis and plan," at $743,000 for the original term, up to $850,000 through renewals running to March 2025. PPS Board of Education, Resolution 6480 (adopted April 19, 2022) Cleveland, the district whose closure language matches Portland's most closely, was an ERS partner too, though earlier: its 2012–2016 portfolio-model transition preceded its current closures and isn't the same as them. ERS case study So both districts, now speaking in near-identical closure language, had at different points hired the same firm whose "small schools cost more" framing underlies it.

And that premise is written into what Portland paid ERS to do. ERS's own analysis plan for the PPS contract, released through a public-records request, lists among the questions it would answer: "What is the 'size premium' in PPS and how does it compare to other districts nationally? How are small vs. large schools spending their resources differently…" So "small schools cost more" wasn't a conclusion PPS reached and then hired ERS to confirm; putting a number on a small-school "size premium" was in the scope of work from the start, by a firm whose own 2008 report is titled "By Design Not Default: Optimizing District Spending on Small High Schools." PPS public records (RFP 2022-002)

And PPS knew what it was buying. In the same proposal, ERS offers as a credential that it helped another district produce a plan that "closed and consolidated under-enrolled school buildings," and lists "portfolio analysis and redesign (consolidations, grade reconfigurations…)" among its services. The timeline matters: the firm was hired in 2022 — years before any closure scenario was public — to run the resource analysis that fed the plan. That doesn't prove the outcome was fixed in advance, but the direction wasn't discovered by a neutral study; it was set by the choice of a firm whose signature work is closing and consolidating schools. PPS public records (RFP 2022-002)

And this predates the current superintendent. The board approved the ERS contract in April 2022 under Guadalupe Guerrero; Kimberlee Armstrong — a Chiefs for Change member — arrived in 2024 and inherited both the engagement and the plan it fed. OPB So the point isn't about any one leader; it's that the framework was already in motion before she walked in.

The framework. The idea even has a name: the "portfolio" model, which the Center on Reinventing Public Education (CRPE), a think tank, credits its founder Paul Hill with having "coined and developed," built around "choice, accountability, and continuous improvement." CRPE CRPE's own page on the model now features a piece titled "Closing schools in a time of enrollment decline," and the model is the source of the "portfolio" language in plans like Boston's.

The toolkits. The approach circulates as ready-made guides. Bellwether's 2025 Navigating Declining Enrollment: A Toolkit for California District Leaders coaches districts on "right-sizing budgets" and rethinking "their portfolio of schools." Bellwether The Keystone Policy Center's 2026 report is titled, literally, Right-Sizing for Student Success, and holds up Cleveland, which "took bold action to right-size and stabilize the district", as a model to copy. Keystone

The money tying it together. The same foundations recur, and it's documented in their own records. ERS's listed philanthropic partners include the Walton Family Foundation, the Gates Foundation, and Carnegie. ERS funders The Walton Family Foundation's own grants database shows years of grants to Chiefs for Change, including $700,000 in 2019 "to build the capacity of and share best practices with education leaders." Walton grants database And Carnegie has funded Chiefs for Change directly, including $600,000 in 2017 "for support of the School and Systems Redesign working group." Carnegie The clearest single thread: the Walton Family Foundation funds both ERS, the advisor whose framing Portland adopted, and Chiefs for Change, the network Portland's superintendent joined.

What this does and doesn't show. It does not prove anyone ordered Portland to close a single school. What it shows is why the plan looks and sounds like everyone else's: Portland is leaning on the same advisor (one it paid), the same framework, and the same toolkits as the other districts, all funded by the same foundations that bankroll the national network its superintendent joined. That is how a national playbook travels without a memo: not by anyone's command, but by shared money and shared ideas converging on the same prescription, the throughline this guide has followed from the start.

Closure tally — Chiefs for Change district leaders#

As of October 2026. These are the 37 Chiefs for Change members who lead an individual school district; the 6 state chiefs and one regional service agency (Puget Sound ESD) are excluded. "Proposed" means an official district plan, board recommendation, or vote — not speculation or rumor. Compiled from each district's local news and board records; network roster.

22 have closed or proposed closing/consolidating schools · 12 no action found · 3 studies underway.

District (state) Leader Status Evidence
Boulder Valley (CO) Rob Anderson Proposed "Resilient Schools" recommendation to close/consolidate (Boulder Reporting Lab)
Portland (OR) Kimberlee Armstrong Proposed Rightsizing plan, up to ~18–20 schools (OPB)
Metro Nashville (TN) Adrienne Battle Closed (2020) North Nashville consolidation, 4 schools (TN Lookout)
Salem-Keizer (OR) Andrea Castañeda Study underway Process that could close up to 8 schools; none named yet (KATU)
Sarasota County (FL) Terry Connor Closed Suncoast Poly / Brookside consolidation (WUSF)
Baltimore City (MD) Jermaine Dawson No 2025 closure proposal predates his July 2026 start (Baltimore Banner)
Arlington (VA) Francisco Durán No Only cautious talk of future consolidation (ARLnow)
Toledo (OH) Romules Durant Closed Edgewater & Mayfair elementaries (Toledo Blade)
Aldine ISD (TX) LaTonya Goffney Closed 6 schools (Houston Landing)
Duncanville ISD (TX) T. Lamar Goree No No proposal found
Jefferson Parish (LA) James Gray Closed ~6 schools consolidated (FOX8)
Jackson (MS) Errick Greene Closed 13 buildings (The 74)
Indianapolis (IN) Aleesia Johnson Closed "Rebuilding Stronger" closures/mergers (Chalkbeat)
Atlanta (GA) Bryan Johnson Closed APS Forward 2040, 16 schools (Rough Draft Atlanta)
Wallingford-Swarthmore (PA) Russell Johnston No No proposal found (short tenure)
Poudre (CO) Brian Kingsley Proposed Closure plan proposed, shelved May 2024 (Colorado Sun)
Dayton (OH) David Lawrence Study underway 2026-27 reconfiguration; no building closure named (Spectrum News)
Prince William County (VA) Latanya McDade Proposed Potomac View Elementary closure recommended (WTOP)
Orange Unified (CA) Rachel Monárrez Study underway Consolidation study; no formal vote (EdSource)
Bernalillo (NM) Matt Montaño No District expanding schools (Rio Rancho Observer)
Cleveland (OH) Warren Morgan Proposed Merger/closing plan announced Nov 2025 (Ideastream)
Reading (PA) Khalid Mumin No Overcrowded / expanding
Guilford County (NC) Whitney Oakley Closed 4 elementaries consolidated (WFDD)
Greeley-Evans (CO) Deirdre Pilch No Growing district, building new schools
Hamilton County (TN) Justin Robertson Closed 3 elementaries consolidated into one (NewsChannel9)
Beaufort County (SC) Frank Rodriguez No No proposal found
Greenville County (SC) W. Burke Royster No Fast-growing; budget cuts only (Fox Carolina)
Everett (WA) Ian Saltzman No Growing; buying land for new school (Herald Net)
Boston (MA) Mary Skipper Closed Frederick MS & West Zone ELC (Boston Globe)
Birmingham City (AL) Mark Sullivan No No closure plan found
Montgomery County (MD) Thomas Taylor Proposed Silver Spring Int'l MS closure recommended, paused (Bethesda Magazine)
Issaquah (WA) Heather Tow-Yick No Adding capacity; no closure (Sammamish Independent)
Orange County (FL) Maria Vazquez Closed 7 schools (Spectrum News 13)
Detroit (MI) Nikolai Vitti Closed 4 schools, more flagged (Chalkbeat)
Philadelphia (PA) Tony Watlington Proposed Facilities plan, ~17 schools (Inquirer)
Plano ISD (TX) Theresa Williams Closed 4 campuses (FOX4)
Little Rock (AR) Jermall Wright Closed "LRSD Forward" consolidations (UALR Public Radio)

How to read this: the point isn't that closing schools is always wrong — it's that this exact move is spreading through one national network, on similar rationales, faster than anyone is checking whether it works.