← PPS Rightsizing Guide

Full analysis

PPS's own audit of the last consolidation

NewAdded November 17: The superintendent's final recommendation, checked against PPS's own packet: a staffing target met without closures, savings PPS has already cut by 20% in a revised memo, a state seismic grant at risk at Marysville, and a size rule the west side doesn't follow


Contents

PPS's own audit of the last consolidation: students held steady, trust didn't#

In 2026 PPS commissioned an independent Equity Audit Evaluation of its last enrollment-balancing effort (the Southeast Guiding Coalition, or SEGC, 2020–23) from Dr. Terrance Green (University of Texas at Austin) and Dr. Havala Hanson, and posted it on its own rightsizing page. PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation SEGC redrew boundaries, reconfigured grades, and moved programs rather than closing schools outright, so it isn't a perfect preview of rightsizing. But it is the best local evidence there is, and it cuts both ways.

  • Students mostly held steady, and some groups gained. Compared with similar students elsewhere in PPS, students at SEGC schools "showed similar patterns across most academic and behavioral outcomes," and the auditors found no evidence of "broad measurable academic or behavioral harm." Several groups showed small reading gains, including elementary students, students at high-poverty schools, multilingual learners, and students in dual-language programs. Black students showed the largest gain in the first year, though it "was not statistically significant in 2024–25 and did not hold under" a second test. The auditors cautioned that these are "small to medium-sized associations rather than evidence that SEGC produced large systemwide gains."
  • The middle-school promise didn't pay off. "No significant academic differences are associated with SEGC changes among middle school students," which the auditors called "important because SEGC's rationale included improving access to robust middle school experiences."
  • Special-education needs were under-planned. The affected schools ended up serving more students in special education than projected (about 5% more on average), and staff described "trying to implement an inclusive neighborhood model without enough paraeducator and special education support." The auditors' conclusion: staffing "must account for actual student needs and not just enrollment numbers alone."
  • Trust collapsed. "Only 3% of staff survey respondents mostly or completely trust the district to handle rightsizing fairly. More than 50% responded that they do not trust the district at all."
  • People felt the outcome was pre-decided. "Perceptions of predetermined outcomes deeply undermined trust", and members concluded "their recommendations were symbolic, constrained, or easily overridden."
  • The costs fell on staff of color and on some communities. In 2022–23, "39% of Staff of Color at SEGC schools left their schools, compared with 21% at non-SEGC schools," and 18% left PPS altogether, against 10% elsewhere. Part of that came from moving dual-language programs, and by 2024–25 the rate had returned to normal, but "the implementation year produced a real loss of Staff of Color." At one school converted to whole-school dual-language, "Black students were almost entirely displaced": the school's share of Black students "dropped from 10% to 2%." Staff described supporting families while "flying blind."

The recommendations read as a direct warning to the current plan: future closures and consolidations "need clearer goals, firmer scope, and more honest discussion of tradeoffs from the start"; engagement must be "accessible, early, and genuinely influential, not reactive to pre-developed plans"; the district must apply its equity lens "through actual decisions, not just symbolic language"; it should use "projection ranges instead of single enrollment estimates"; and it should "define 'well-resourced schools' through a concrete, funded, and feasible staffing model" before using that phrase to justify closures. Most pointedly: "If a proposed closure, consolidation, or boundary change is intended to create well-resourced schools, PPS should be able to demonstrate not only that enrollment numbers improve on paper, but that students will experience more stable staffing, stronger supports, broader programming, and more equitable access." PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation

In fairness, PPS is right to cite this audit's student results: they are the best local evidence that a consolidation doesn't have to set students back. They are not evidence that this plan, about four times larger and built around closures, will move students forward; the auditors themselves warned against reading them that way. And in staff's written answers to the board, PPS has cited the audit as recommending that a plan for closed buildings be "decided before closure votes, not after." PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19 We could not find that recommendation in either of the audit's two published reports. The same answer says PPS will build its plan for closed buildings "as part of implementation planning," which is to say, after.