The districts PPS chose as models#
When PPS staff laid out how to design this process at a March 31, 2026 board work session, they offered three peer districts to learn from: San Antonio, Seattle, and Denver, alongside Oregon PTA guidance. Staff pointed to San Antonio for its iterative decision framework, to Seattle for how it defined a well-resourced school, and to Denver for its closure criteria and equity guardrails. PPS Board of Education meetings (March 31, 2026 work session) Every lesson named was about process. Nothing presented that evening described how those processes turned out. Here is how they did, by each district's own records. None delivered what PPS is now promising Portland: stability, reinvestment, and better-resourced schools.
Seattle called its closures off. In September 2024, the district whose "well-resourced schools" framing PPS borrowed proposed closing as many as 21 schools to save up to $31.5 million. Within two months the list was down to four and the projected savings to about $5.5 million, against a deficit near $100 million, and the board unanimously canceled the plan. Seattle's own numbers show why: the average closure saved about $1.5 million a year, and the final plan would have left one merged school (Stevens and Montlake, 322 students) still below the district's own 400-student benchmark. In fairness, Seattle hasn't solved its budget problem the other way either, and its leaders say closures may return. But once the numbers were real, it decided closing schools wasn't worth the cost. KUOW · SPS FAQ · SPS analysis of the four schools
Denver closed ten schools, and its "savings" were mostly money that followed the students. Denver's superintendent put the recommendation's budget savings at $29.9 million, then, in the same table, subtracted $23.3 million that simply follows displaced students to their new schools. What was left: $6.6 million, to be "reinvested" through the regular budget. DPS recommendation package, p. 28 Days earlier, voters had approved a $975 million bond on the promise that every school would get something; the closure list came out two days after it passed, and a Denver Gazette analysis found the campuses later closed or restructured were allocated far less than schools that stayed open (about $2.6 million versus $4.1 million on average). Denver Gazette Enrollment then fell faster than projected, and Denver's superintendent now says he expects to override the board's own four-year closure moratorium. Chalkbeat This is the closest parallel to Armstrong's promise to reinvest "all of the funds from closures and consolidations directly back into schools": in Denver, most of that money was the students' own per-pupil funding moving with them. In fairness, about half of Denver's displaced students chose higher-rated schools, helped by guaranteed priority and busing through open school choice, which PPS's scenarios don't offer. Chalkbeat
San Antonio closed 15 schools, and is closing more. San Antonio ISD's board voted 5–2 in November 2023 to close 15 schools and merge or redesign five more. A week into the next school year, about one in five affected students hadn't shown up; enrollment has fallen every year since; and the district still faces a structural deficit of roughly $45.9 million. In March 2026 it voted to close another school, Rhodes Middle, that its own 2023 review had rated safe. TPR · SAISD · KSAT
And there is a Portland connection. Before that vote, San Antonio commissioned an equity audit from Dr. Terrance Green and Dr. Havala Hanson, the same researchers PPS later hired to review its own last consolidation. They found that students from San Antonio's previous closures had higher absence rates and lower grades than matched peers, that the receiving schools were academically no better than the ones closing, and that most staff experienced the process as a "done deal." Their report reached the district three days before the board voted to proceed. SAISD equity audit (Nov 2023) PPS then hired the same team. In Portland they found that students fared better than in San Antonio, but that the process did similar damage to trust, and they issued similar warnings (see "PPS's own audit").
The same number, everywhere. San Antonio drew its line at 350 elementary students; Denver called 350 "sustainable"; Seattle used the state's 400-student model school; PPS uses 360. In none of them did that number decide which schools closed (building condition, location, and enrollment patterns did), and in none was it tied to student outcomes.
So why hold these districts up at all? PPS chose them as models for how to run this process, and has not told the board or families what happened after those processes ran. The board should ask, before December 15, whether staff reviewed those results, and if they did, why they weren't presented.