← PPS Rightsizing Guide

Full analysis

The enrollment forecast

NewAdded November 17: The superintendent's final recommendation, checked against PPS's own packet: a staffing target met without closures, savings PPS has already cut by 20% in a revised memo, a state seismic grant at risk at Marysville, and a size rule the west side doesn't follow


Contents

The enrollment forecast: solid for the district, shaky school by school#

Every closure in Scenarios A and B rests on one input: Portland State University's forecast of how many students each school will have in 2031-32. Asked on OPB why PPS wouldn't have an outside auditor check its enrollment data, Superintendent Armstrong said the district doesn't "question those numbers," allowed that "when you get into the individual schools there has been some fluctuation … some schools may be a little over, some may be a little under," and added: "I would love for someone to show us the data where our numbers are off." OPB: Think Out Loud, Oct 16 So we checked, using Portland State's own reports.

District-wide, the forecast has earned its reputation. Portland State's one-year forecast of total PPS enrollment has a median miss of about 0.5% since 2010, and every forecast since schools reopened in 2022 has stayed within about 1% of what actually happened. PSU forecast, Table 4.4 The decline is real, and this guide doesn't dispute it.

School by school is different, and Portland State doesn't report it. Closures are decided one school at a time, yet the forecast report checks its accuracy only for the district total and by grade; its school-by-school tables carry no error ranges. PSU forecast, Sec. 4.4 So we compared each school's past forecasts with what it actually enrolled, using every Portland State forecast for PPS posted since 2014 (about 4,200 forecasts in all), and confirmed the actual counts against PPS's own enrollment records. PSU forecast archive · PPS 10-year enrollment history Setting aside the COVID years, when nearly every school was over-forecast, here is how far off a school's forecast typically landed. Each cell shows the typical (median) miss, then how many schools in 100 missed by more than 20%, for forecasts made in normal years (2014–19) and since schools reopened (2022–25):

Years out Normal years Since 2022
1 3% · 1 in 100 3% · 0 in 100
2 5% · 2 in 100 6% · 3 in 100
3 6% · 8 in 100 8% · 11 in 100
4 7% · 13 in 100 10% · 17 in 100
6 10% · 22 in 100 not yet measurable

PPS's scenarios are judged six years out. The district measures every school against its size lines in 2031-32, six years past the forecast's latest data. In normal years, a six-year school forecast missed by about 10%, and more than one school in five missed by over 20%. The recent forecasts are, if anything, missing faster.

That margin is wider than many of the calls. In Portland State's newest forecast, 16 schools land within 10% of PPS's size lines (360 students for K-5, 500 for middle and K-8) in 2031-32, and 31 within 20%. For them, "sustainable" or "unsustainable" sits inside the forecast's ordinary miss. Rose City Park, which closes under Scenario A, is projected above the line, at 370. PSU forecast, Table 5.5 · PPS scenarios

The number for the same school keeps moving. Between the 2022 and 2026 editions of the forecast, the 2031-32 projection fell by about a third at Buckman (369 to 239), Lewis (301 to 201), and Woodstock, which would take in Clark's Mandarin program (488 to 325). Rose City Park's rose from 375 to 513, then fell back to 370. Some swings follow boundary changes PPS made in Southeast Portland; others simply reflect a new year of data. Either way, a school's fate can turn on which year's forecast happens to be on the table.

Dual-language programs are shakier still. Forecasts for individual immersion programs, the units PPS proposes to move, missed by a median of 17% four years out, and nearly four in ten missed by more than 20%. In the 2022 edition, Beach's Spanish program was overstated by 49% and Sitton's understated by 32%.

Irvington shows both kinds of miss. Longtime Irvington teachers say Portland State has always overstated the school. For a stretch it did: forecasts published from 2016 to 2021 mostly ran high, and further off than for most schools (the 2021 edition was 27% too high one year out, against 8% for the district). Since 2023 the miss has flipped. The forecast has predicted decline every year while Irvington grew three years running, from 228 students to 259; the 2023 edition's estimate for fall 2025 was 19% low. Irvington is one of only five schools under-forecast in each of the last three one-year forecasts, and the newest edition again has it shrinking, to 223 by 2031-32.

In fairness, a better forecast wouldn't by itself lift Irvington over 360: even 20% more than 223 is 268. The forecast's weakness is an argument about how PPS is deciding more than about any single school. Portland State does produce low and high scenarios, but only for the district as a whole (36,668 to 40,881 students in 2031-32); only the middle scenario is broken out school by school, and PPS treats it as exact. PSU forecast, Tables 5.2–5.5 Before drawing permanent lines through those numbers, the district should publish the range around each school's projection, and Portland State's own record of how its school forecasts have held up. (Our method and full results are available on request.)