The equity case for closures, checked against the data#
On October 20, after staff presented the scenarios' "equity analysis," two board members made the most forceful case anyone has made for this plan. Director Rashelle Chase-Miller, who represents Zone 4, grew up in Northeast Portland, and attended its schools, said she was "trembling with anger" and called the gaps the slides showed "immoral." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Vice Chair Michelle DePass, also raised in Portland, called the same slides "appalling." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Both spoke from their own and their families' experience of racism in Portland and in PPS, and nothing here questions that.
This page checks their argument, claim by claim, against PPS's own presentation and the state's data. Every quote links to its moment in the meeting video. The short version: they are right about the problem, and the plan's logic for fixing it doesn't hold up.
1. The "immoral" numbers measure building size, not resources
"The number of our focal students who do not currently attend fully resourced schools is shocking." — Director Chase-Miller (video)
The slides Chase-Miller and DePass reacted to didn't measure resources. They measured how many students attend a "sustainable" school, which PPS defines as a school at or above its enrollment line: 360 students for a K-5 school, 500 for a K-8 or middle school. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Nothing in that measure counts teachers, counselors, class sizes, or how students are doing. DePass described the same slide as "the number of students currently not being served." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting It is a count of students in small buildings.
That matters because the measure scores itself. Close a small school, move its students into a bigger one, and every one of them is now "in a sustainable school." That is why staff could report that under both scenarios "every focal group gains more than students overall." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting The gain is in the definition. Staff also conceded that students in special education "start lowest" on this measure "and they also remain lowest." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting PPS's own districtwide slide shows the same pattern, with special education lowest in every column:
Two ways to score the same moves
36% → 82%
of North Portland students in a "sustainable" school by 2031-32: with no changes vs. under either scenario, on PPS's own slide. Every focal group rises further, to between 80% and 92%.
7 of 14
closing schools send their students to a school with higher reading results. The other 7 send them somewhere lower.
"Sustainable" means a school at or above PPS's size line (360 students for a K-5 school, 500 for a K-8 or middle school). Moving students into a bigger building raises the first number automatically. Only the second measures anything about how students are doing.
Where the logic breaks: a number that rises whenever a building closes can't be the evidence that closing the building helps. PPS says size is what lets a school staff a full program. That may be true, but it's a promise about staffing, and the staffing plan hasn't been published (see point 3). PPS's own auditors drew the same line after the last consolidation: the district "should be able to demonstrate not only that enrollment numbers improve on paper, but that students will experience more stable staffing, stronger supports, broader programming, and more equitable access." PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation
2. The plan doesn't send Black students to the schools that are working for them
"How are you going to ensure that black and brown kids in PPS get an education that's comparable to what your students are getting?" — Director Chase-Miller (video)
That's the right question to ask of the plan. The research is clear that closures help students only when they land in a clearly better school, and fewer than half do. CREDO (2017) So we checked where Portland's students land (full results: "Where students land"). In reading, 8 of the 14 closing schools send students to a higher-scoring school and 6 to a lower-scoring one; in math, 6 and 7, with one about even. The steepest drops are in North Portland and the dual-language programs: Peninsula's students move from a school where 44% meet the reading standard to Rosa Parks, at 15%, and the Spanish-immersion students from Beach and James John move to César Chávez, at 20%. ODE: Assessment Group Reports
For Black students specifically, the state hides results at all 14 closing schools, because fewer than 10 were tested in each grade. So no public data shows how Black students at those schools are doing, or that they'd do better after moving. The receiving schools are a different story. Where the state does report Black students' results there, most are below the district's own Black-student average, including King and Rosa Parks, which would receive Sabin's and Peninsula's students, about 60 Black students between them. PPS: Enrollment of Underserved Groups, Oct 1, 2025
Chase-Miller warned against this herself. At the board's March 31 work session, reporting back for a small group of directors, she named as something to avoid "adverse impacts to students from communities that have been historically underserved," along with "paternalistic perspectives like: the underserved kids will be better off by joining the privileged kids, based on assumptions that we may or may not have about both communities." PPS Board of Education meetings (March 31, 2026 work session) Her October 20 argument leans on a version of that assumption, that moving is itself the help, and in North and outer Southeast Portland most moves don't even reach a stronger school: they stay within the same high-poverty neighborhoods.
In fairness, a school's average mostly reflects who attends it, and for students in poverty some comparisons favor the receiving school: at King, they outscore their peers at Sabin. And PPS's own audit of its last consolidation found small reading gains at the affected schools for several groups, including multilingual learners and, in the first year, Black students, though the Black students' gain faded the next year and didn't hold up in a second test. PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation That's real, and it's the best evidence the plan's defenders have. It came from boundary and program changes, though, not from closing 14 schools, and it shows students holding steady more than moving to stronger schools. Where the logic breaks: "comparable to what your students are getting" would mean sending students to schools where students like them do better. For most of the moves in North Portland, the state's data says the opposite, and PPS hasn't published anything that says otherwise.
3. "No one is coming to save us," and this plan doesn't either
"What money do you think they have for us? No one is coming to save us. This is our moment to make a change for our kids." — Director Chase-Miller (video)
She's right about Salem. But the plan isn't a rescue. The only estimate PPS has given of what closures save, presented once at the October 20 board meeting with no analysis behind it, is about $14 million in "operational savings" under Scenario A and $11 million under Scenario B, against a $65 million gap. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting The same slide claims what that buys. With no closures, the schools' share of the cuts is $32.3 million, about 223 positions. Under Scenario A it falls to $18.3 million, about 126 positions; under Scenario B, to $21.3 million, about 147. The savings could "potentially preserve or reinvest the equivalent of" about 97 (A) or 76 (B) positions. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Those 223 are only the school-based share: on November 2 the superintendent said up to 450 full-time positions could be cut districtwide. KPTV, Nov 2 So even the larger plan still cuts more than a hundred positions from schools, and PPS hasn't said whether the savings recur in later years or what they are net of. And she was explicit that these are "planning estimates, not final staffing decisions or guaranteed reinvestments." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting The cost and staffing analysis comes with her November 17 recommendation. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting
Nor do closures move money toward the students the argument is about. Spending per student follows the receiving school: students moving into high-poverty schools land where spending is already higher, and students moving into large, lower-poverty schools land where it's lower (see "Where students land"). Nothing in the savings estimate is earmarked for North or outer Southeast Portland, for Title I schools, or for any focal group. And the board was given these numbers before it got answers to its own questions about them: as of October 19, directors' written questions on the net savings from closing a school, the cost of added busing, and the cost of moving programs were all still "In process." PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19
Chase-Miller has pressed staff on exactly this. In written questions on October 6, she asked, "What specific resources will students gain in the receiving school?", "What will PPS do if projected savings do not translate into school-level improvements?", and "How will PPS protect student belonging, cultural identity, and school-community relationships, especially for racially minoritized students?" As of October 19, the answer to all three was "In process." PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19
Where the logic breaks: "make a change for our kids" assumes the change carries resources to them. As of October 20, the plan commits none.
4. Merging can dissolve the funding meant for these students
"I don't want to underfund our historically underserved kids." — Vice Chair DePass, recalling an 1800s Portland board that refused a segregated school the $800 it needed (video)
The plan has a case of exactly that. Brentwood Middle School is a Title I school where nearly half the students (46.5%) are from the groups PPS counts as historically underserved, and where, as Director Stephanie Engelsman relayed from its families, "our black and brown kids are the majority of our school and they love it." Under Scenario A it would absorb half of Sellwood Middle School. Reading from district data, Engelsman said the share of Brentwood's students from underserved racial groups would fall from 46.5% to 26.9%, students in poverty from 57.5% to 32.1%, and multilingual learners from 18.6% to 9%, and the school would no longer qualify for Title I. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting PPS's own enrollment count matches her figures for Brentwood today (listed under its former name, Lane). PPS: Enrollment of Underserved Groups, Oct 1, 2025 The Scenario A figures are hers; PPS hasn't published them.
Brentwood Middle School today, and after it absorbs half of Sellwood (Scenario A)
Share of Brentwood's students in each group. Today's figures are PPS's October 1, 2025 count; the Scenario A figures are as Director Engelsman read them on October 20. Brentwood is a Title I school today; under either scenario it would not be.
Brentwood todayAfter Scenario A
Scenario B is nearly the same: 25.5%, 30.6% and 9.2%.
Show as a table
| Closing school | Brentwood today | After Scenario A |
|---|---|---|
| Students from underserved racial groups | 46.5% | 26.9% |
| Students experiencing poverty | 57.5% | 32.1% |
| Multilingual learners | 18.6% | 9% |
Her point was about what happens to the money that "follows the kids": "if the same number of kids moves to a larger school and they become a much smaller percentage of that greater school, there simply are less resources that can be dedicated to them." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Elsewhere the problem runs the other way. The special-education parent group SEPTSA's preliminary analysis found the plan would further concentrate students at higher-poverty receiving schools that may not have room to meet projected needs. SEPTSA
In fairness, PPS says the district doesn't lose Title I money when students move. In a written answer about Buckman, staff explained that the federal dollars follow the district's count of students in poverty and go to whichever schools clear PPS's threshold, 33% of students directly certified for state benefits; when a school falls short, "the district redirects those funds to other PPS schools." PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19 So the money stays in PPS. It just doesn't stay with these students: a merged Brentwood would have about 32% of its students directly certified, just under the line.
Where the logic breaks: DePass's story is a warning against taking resources from the students who need them most. Breaking up a Title I school doesn't take the money out of PPS, but it takes it away from the school these students attend.
5. "Always on the menu": the plan puts the same neighborhoods on it again
"Any of us who grew up in North Portland or inner Northeast or outer Southeast know that we are always on the menu." — Director Chase-Miller (video)
That is the most powerful line of the night, and it's an argument against this plan. Ten of the 14 proposed closures are in North and Southeast Portland. Under either scenario, a third of North Portland's K-8 students would change schools, the highest share in the city, including 39% of its multilingual learners. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Chase-Miller acknowledged it herself: "our communities stand to face the most change." (video)
Near the end of the meeting, DePass objected to families describing the plan as "redlining" or "segregation," calling those terms "loaded and actually just not correct." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Taken literally, she has a point: redlining was a housing and lending practice, and no one is drawing new red lines. But the families using the word, including a Marysville counselor who told the board that "pushing students and their families to different schools… sounds much more like redlining to me," PPS: Oct 20 board meeting are describing the same pattern PPS's own staff named: the map this plan works from is redlining's legacy, and the burden lands where it always has.
In fairness, staff say that districtwide, students in each focal group move at close to the overall rate, and that both scenarios also move students into Title I schools. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting The imbalance is by neighborhood, not by student group. But that is exactly the pattern "always on the menu" describes.
6. Integrating Portland's schools, or sorting them? The plan does both, and no one chose which
If this is an equity plan, a basic question is whether it leaves students in more integrated schools or less. PPS hasn't said. Its equity slides count students in "sustainable" schools, and none of them show who ends up in school with whom. So we checked, comparing each closing school with its main receiving school on two measures: the share of students who are white, from the state's October 2025 enrollment count, and the share in poverty, from PPS's own count. ODE: Fall Membership Report 2025-26 · PPS: Enrollment of Underserved Groups, Oct 1, 2025
White students: closing school vs. the school receiving its students
Share of each school's students who are white, October 1, 2025 (Oregon Department of Education). PPS overall: 54%. Each closing school is paired with its main receiving school.
Closing schoolSchool receiving its students
Sorted from the biggest increase to the biggest decrease.
Show as a table
| Closing school | Result | Receiving school | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marysville | 36% | Arleta | 62% |
| Beach | 46% | Chief Joseph | 69% |
| Buckman | 62% | Abernethy | 76% |
| Lewis | 65% | Duniway | 78% |
| Irvington | 62% | Beverly Cleary | 71% |
| Woodmere | 34% | Whitman | 36% |
| James John | 32% | Sitton | 33% |
| Maplewood | 67% | Hayhurst | 67% |
| Rose City Park | 46% | Scott | 38% |
| Sellwood | 80% | Hosford | 70% |
| Creston | 66% | Atkinson | 53% |
| Stephenson | 68% | Markham | 49% |
| Peninsula | 45% | Rosa Parks | 14% |
| Sabin | 63% | King | 24% |
There's no consistent direction. Five closing schools send their students to a school whose white share is more than 5 points higher, six to one more than 5 points lower, and three to one about the same. That's what you'd expect from how the pairs were drawn. Explaining one of them, staff wrote that "the quantitative model optimizes for building utilization." PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19 Each closing school is matched with a nearby building that has room, so the result follows the city's existing neighborhood lines.
At one end, students move into whiter, wealthier schools. Five closures send students to a school that is both whiter and lower-poverty: Irvington to Beverly Cleary (62% white to 71%; 21% of students in poverty to 11%), Buckman to Abernethy (62% to 76%; 36% to 11%), Lewis to Duniway (65% to 78%; 22% to 8%), Beach's neighborhood students to Chief Joseph (46% to 69%; 35% to 22%), and Marysville to Arleta (36% to 62%; 58% to 25%). Their students of color become a smaller minority in their new school.
At the other end, poverty concentrates. Peninsula's students move to Rosa Parks, where 79% of students are in poverty, against 38% at Peninsula; the share who are white falls from 45% to 14%. Sabin's students move to King: 63% white to 24%, and 28% in poverty to 51%. Nine of the 14 closing schools send students to a school with a higher poverty rate.
Students in poverty: closing school vs. the school receiving its students
Share of each school's students directly certified for state benefits such as SNAP, PPS's measure of poverty, October 1, 2025. PPS overall: 31.5%.
Closing schoolSchool receiving its students
Sorted from the biggest increase to the biggest decrease.
Show as a table
| Closing school | Result | Receiving school | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peninsula | 38% | Rosa Parks | 79% |
| Stephenson | 10% | Markham | 38% |
| Sabin | 28% | King | 51% |
| Rose City Park | 33% | Scott | 52% |
| Sellwood | 13% | Hosford | 26% |
| Creston | 24% | Atkinson | 32% |
| Maplewood | 20% | Hayhurst | 26% |
| James John | 54% | Sitton | 60% |
| Woodmere | 59% | Whitman | 64% |
| Irvington | 21% | Beverly Cleary | 11% |
| Beach | 35% | Chief Joseph | 22% |
| Lewis | 22% | Duniway | 8% |
| Buckman | 36% | Abernethy | 11% |
| Marysville | 58% | Arleta | 25% |
The dual-language moves split schools along language and ethnic lines. At Beach and James John, the plan sends Spanish-immersion students one way and everyone else another. Beach's immersion students go to César Chávez, which is 16% white and 64% Latino, while its neighborhood students go to Chief Joseph, which is 69% white. PPS's own auditors found that the last time it converted a school to whole-school dual-language, the change displaced "non-DLI neighborhood families along racial lines," and the school's share of Black students fell from 10% to 2%. PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation Director La Forte relayed in writing that to James John families, whole-school dual-language for North Portland "felt like 'defacto segregation.'" PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19
Some moves do integrate. Sellwood's students would join Brentwood, Stephenson's would join Markham, Rose City Park's would join Scott, and Creston's would join Atkinson. Each of those produces a more mixed school, and Brentwood shows what that can cost: it loses its Title I funding (see point 4).
In fairness, a citywide plan has real reasons behind it: closing only North Portland's schools would put those neighborhoods "on the menu" again, and PPS's auditors recommended that future closures take in every part of the city. Integration also looks different depending on whose students you count. Irvington's students move into a whiter school, but Beverly Cleary itself becomes more diverse.
Where the logic breaks: a plan presented as an equity plan should be able to say whether it integrates schools or sorts them. PPS's auditors told it to publish, "for each proposed closure, consolidation, program move, or boundary change option," an impact summary "disaggregated by race and ethnicity, multilingual learner status, special education status, and poverty." PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation PPS hasn't. Its equity analysis measures building size, and this plan integrates some schools and sorts others without anyone having chosen either.
7. "My kids' school is gonna stay under-resourced"
"We don't have enough teachers of color, we don't have enough experienced teachers in these schools, and that is showing up in our students' outcomes … My kids' school is gonna stay under-resourced. And that's a school full of black kids in North Portland." — Director Chase-Miller (video)
Here Chase-Miller named both the cause and the limit of the plan. The cause she named is staffing: too few experienced teachers and teachers of color, and substitutes who won't take jobs in North Portland. The superintendent said the same thing earlier that evening, pointing to the district's past effort to raise substitute pay in North Portland schools and to the research on teacher turnover: "if we have an opportunity to … better support and stabilize those schools with staffing, our students will be in stronger environments." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting
Closing buildings doesn't hire or keep teachers. Consolidations move staff around, and in the first year of the last one PPS ran, 39% of staff of color at the affected schools left them, nearly twice the rate elsewhere (see "What it means for teachers and staff" and "PPS's own audit of the last consolidation"). And by her own account, the plan leaves her children's majority-Black North Portland school as under-resourced as it is now.
Where the logic breaks: if the problem is staffing in North and outer Southeast schools, the fix is staffing in North and outer Southeast schools. The plan doesn't commit to any.
8. "If your school is doing okay … you can afford to wait"
"If your school is doing okay and your kids are doing okay, then you can afford to wait. But my kids cannot wait." — Director Chase-Miller (video)
This is aimed at families from schools like Irvington, including the author of this guide, and it lands partly: Irvington's students would move to a higher-scoring school. But the people asking the board to slow down that night weren't only from lower-poverty schools. They included North Portland and Spanish-immersion families, the Marysville counselor, the teachers' union, and SEPTSA, whose concerns are about students with disabilities across the city.
Who are "your students"? Chase-Miller framed the plan's critics as families whose children aren't "black and brown kids," who "don't want the benefits," and who can "afford to wait." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting The record doesn't support that line. Among those who objected that night were a Marysville counselor speaking for students from "the same historically marginalized community of color that PPS claims to be centering," PPS: Oct 20 board meeting and Spanish-speaking immersion families who, as Director Engelsman reported from a listening session, were "furious." PPS: Oct 20 board meeting And the schools the plan closes look like the district. Of their 4,258 students, 32% are from the groups PPS counts as historically underserved (Black, Latino, Native American, Pacific Islander, and multiracial students), against 35.6% across PPS's elementary and K-8 schools. At James John, Woodmere, and Marysville they are the majority. Even at the closing schools with the fewest, they are 13% to 22% of students, before counting Asian American students, whom PPS leaves out of that measure. PPS: Enrollment of Underserved Groups, Oct 1, 2025
Drawing the line as one set of neighborhoods against another doesn't describe the opposition, and it erases the families of color on the side of the line she put her opponents on. It also splits communities that have more in common here than not: none of them has been shown that this plan will serve their children better.
And it isn't the opponents who are getting ahead of the evidence. The board presentation that will "dig into the data of the focal groups, special education, multilingual learners, Black and Native" students is scheduled for November 4, PPS: Oct 20 board meeting after the scenarios were drawn up, and the equity impact statement staff promised comes with the November recommendation. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Asking to see the data on Black students before a plan is sold as being for them isn't a luxury. It's the least the equity case should require.
"What solutions are you bringing to the table?"
"So, all of you who are here to protest this decision … What solutions are you bringing to the table?" — Director Chase-Miller (video)
It's a fair challenge, and "slow down" isn't an answer by itself. Here are five, each aimed at the problems she named:
- Staff stability, in writing, for Title I and focal-group schools. Retention pay for experienced teachers, the substitute-pay approach the superintendent described, and a commitment that any closure savings go there first.
- Class-size caps in writing before the vote (see "What the superintendent told Irvington families").
- A receiving-school test. No closure unless PPS publishes, for that pair, evidence that the receiving school serves the moving students' groups better, including students with disabilities and Black students where data exists.
- Fight for the money together. The board, the teachers' union, and families all want the state to release its school reserve fund. KATU Make that the shared fight, in Salem, before any school closes (see "What we're asking for").
- Put the equity data first. Hold the November 4 presentation on Black, Native, multilingual, and special-education students, and the equity impact statement, before the recommendation is final, and let them shape it.
Questions this raises for the board:
- Will PPS publish, for every closing school, how the students moving out compare with students at the receiving school, by focal group?
- How much of the estimated savings will go to Title I and focal-group schools, and will that be in writing before the vote?
- Will the November 4 data on Black and Native students, and the equity impact statement, come before the recommendation is final?
- What happens to Brentwood's Title I funding, and to the students it pays for, if it absorbs half of Sellwood?