Done to North Portland, in the name of improvement#
The case for this plan is that North Portland can't wait, and that doing something is better than doing nothing. North Portland has heard that before. Here is what "something" has looked like.
- 1970s: integration, one way. PPS desegregated by busing Black students out of Albina and closing the middle grades in their neighborhoods, while white schools went largely untouched. Ron Herndon called it "the most racist form of integration I've ever seen." It took the threat of a boycott by every Black student in the district to change it. Willamette Week
- 1980s–2000s: a transfer policy that emptied the neighborhood. Open transfers were meant to promote integration. Instead, they let families in gentrifying neighborhoods send their children to whiter, wealthier schools elsewhere; by the late 1990s PPS schools were more segregated than the neighborhoods around them, and the under-enrolled schools left behind lost resources and became closure targets. LSE US Centre
- Mid-2000s: the K-8 conversions, the closest parallel to today. Facing declining enrollment and, in the superintendent's words, a "way-reduced-resource moment," PPS merged elementary and middle schools into K-8s. They landed mostly in North and Northeast Portland and other lower-income communities; the west side kept its middle schools, and the electives and programs that came with them. Superintendent Carole Smith later said the conversions were done "too quickly without planning." Willamette Week (2015) Families then waited years for the middle schools to come back, Willamette Week (2016) and Tubman reopened as a middle school only in 2018. KATU
- 2012: closed with little warning. The board closed Humboldt Elementary and the Harriet Tubman girls' academy in North and Northeast Portland, with parents saying they had no real chance to respond. KATU
- 2020s: the last consolidation. At one school PPS converted to whole-school dual-language, the share of Black students fell from 10% to 2%, by PPS's own audit. PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation
And now. Under either scenario, a third of North Portland's K-8 students change schools, the highest share in the city, including 39% of its multilingual learners. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Spanish-immersion students from Beach and James John would be sent across the city to César Chávez, and James John families told a board member that whole-school dual-language for North Portland "felt like 'defacto segregation.'" PPS: Board Q&A document, Oct 19 Immersion families elsewhere in the city describe the same fear of being uprooted. Under both scenarios, Spanish immersion from Beach, James John, and Sitton would consolidate at César Chávez, and the middle-school programs at César Chávez and Ockley Green would move to George in St. Johns. One Southeast parent told KGW that gathering Spanish-immersion families at fewer campuses amounts to "handing ICE a free reign" to find them, and that families she knows are afraid to say so publicly. A Vietnamese-immersion parent, whose community largely arrived as refugees, said moving their program would reopen the trauma of being "separated and relocated." KGW
The pattern isn't bad intentions. It's that big reorganizations, done fast, in lean years, keep landing on the same neighborhoods, and the district keeps learning the cost afterward. The improvements that did last, the 1980 investment in Albina schools and the middle schools that came back in 2018, came after North Portland families organized and pushed. (See "Portland has stopped closures before".)
Portland has stopped closures before#
This isn't the first time Portland families have faced school closures. When they organized across neighborhoods and kept up the pressure, the board has backed down, and when the money ran out, Portland has gone and found more. Both halves of that history matter now.
The Black United Front, 1979–1982
It started with who carried the burden. In the 1970s, PPS desegregated by busing Black students out of North and Northeast Portland and closing the middle grades in their neighborhoods, while white schools went largely untouched. Ron Herndon called it "the most racist form of integration I've ever seen." In July 1979, the Black United Front, an alliance of 15 Albina churches, the NAACP, and eight neighborhood associations, called on all 7,400 of the district's Black students to boycott school that fall, with alternative schools ready for anyone who stayed out. By the end of August, the district had given in to most of its demands. When reforms stalled, the Front staged a one-day boycott in April 1980; new board members elected that spring fired the superintendent in June. Willamette Week The 1980 desegregation plan that followed promised investment in Albina schools and a new middle school. LSE US Centre
1982: the board broke that promise, and paid for it. On March 5, 1982, a reshaped board voted 5–2 to put the new Harriet Tubman Middle School in the Boise building instead of the Eliot site it had promised, closing the last K-8 school in Portland's Black community and scattering its 350 students to five other schools. Two new members provided the margin, over the objection of the district's own superintendent, Matthew Prophet. Public History PDX · Portland Observer (Apr 15, 1982) What followed made governing impossible:
- The meetings stopped working. About 150 protesters chanting "Eliot, Eliot" filled the next board meeting until the board adjourned and went home. The chair then moved a meeting into a small room closed to the public, which three of his own colleagues called a violation of the open-meetings law. Portland Observer (Apr 15, 1982)
- The city saw it. More than 500 people marched from Alberta Park, Public History PDX and parents kept their children home in a one-day boycott on April 19. Portland Observer (Apr 8, 1982)
- It got personal. The Front picketed outside the home of Dean Gisvold, the director who had moved the Boise plan. Portland Observer (Apr 8, 1982)
- The board tried the courts, and backed off. Directors planned to meet with lawyers about injunctions against protests at board meetings, Portland Observer (Apr 22, 1982) and filed suit on April 20. The next day they put it aside for mediation. Public History PDX
The community set the terms of the talks. The Front agreed to mediation only if the board said it was willing to reconsider, dropped the injunction while talks ran, started by April 26, and decided by May 10. Prophet urged the board to accept, and it did. A mediator from the U.S. Justice Department ran the sessions, with Herndon, the Urban League, and the Albina Ministerial Alliance across the table from Prophet and two directors, one of whom had voted for Boise. Portland Observer (Apr 29, 1982) In May the board voted 6–1 to put Tubman at Eliot after all. Herndon called it a victory for the parents who kept their children home and the groups that rallied, boycotted, and demonstrated, and said the closed-door sessions had let people stop protecting their public images. Portland Observer (May 13, 1982) That is the pattern: pressure that made the status quo untenable, and a way for the majority to change course without simply surrendering.
Tubman still matters to this fight. Since 2018, it has been the middle school for Irvington, Sabin, King, and Boise-Eliot/Humboldt; two of them, Irvington and Sabin, are on today's closure list. KATU
The Jefferson cluster: closed more than anywhere else
North Portland's Jefferson cluster, the schools that feed what was Oregon's only majority-Black high school, has absorbed closure after closure. In 2010, a board majority moved to close Jefferson High itself; hundreds of mostly Black supporters filled the boardroom, Portland Mercury and the building stayed open, though as a college-focused magnet school rather than a full neighborhood high school. American School & University In April 2012, the board voted to close Humboldt Elementary and, 5–2, the Harriet Tubman girls' academy, with parents saying they had no real chance to respond. KATU
So when PPS proposed more closures and mergers there in early 2013, families were ready. They pointed out that the district had closed more Jefferson-cluster schools in a decade than in every other cluster combined, and that the district's transfer policy let families send their children to schools elsewhere, then cited the emptier buildings left behind as the reason to close them. About 200 people rallied at Jefferson in January under signs reading "Stop racist school closures." Portland Observer (Jan 30, 2013) Families and educators packed a February 9 board hearing, where speakers demanded a moratorium on closures, PPS: Feb 9, 2013 hearing minutes and the teachers' union president apologized for not joining parents sooner. On February 12, the superintendent's revised recommendation closed no neighborhood school. Organizers credited one thing above all: they refused the district's attempt to divide them by race and class. The Indypendent · Socialist Worker
The demand those families made, a neighborhood middle school, came true four years later, when the board reopened Tubman as a middle school for North and Northeast Portland. KATU Today, Scenario A closes four more schools in the Jefferson–Roosevelt region. Jefferson–Roosevelt regional summary North Portland is on the list again.
Other cities, and the money
Peer cities have stopped closures recently. Oakland's board voted in 2022 to close or shrink 11 schools; after a year of walkouts, sit-ins, and a hunger strike, three seats changed hands in the November election, and in January 2023 the new board rescinded the closures still to come. EdSource San Francisco dropped its closure plan in October 2024, after the superintendent resigned amid backlash from families and city leaders. EdSource Seattle cancelled its plan once the savings shrank (see "The districts PPS chose as models").
Portland has also raised the money before. In 2003, with state cuts threatening to cost Portland one in five of its teachers, Multnomah County voters passed a temporary 1.25% county income tax, about three-quarters of it for schools. Multnomah County · NW Labor Press In 2019, more than 20,000 Oregon teachers walked out, about 25,000 people rallied in Portland, and five days later the Legislature passed the Student Success Act, roughly $1 billion a year for schools from a tax on large businesses. NW Labor Press · OPB
What the wins had in common
- A coalition too broad to split. The Black United Front was churches, the NAACP, and neighborhood associations together; the 2013 families refused to be divided by race and class. A fight school against school is a fight the district wins.
- Pressure that didn't let up. Boycotts, packed meetings, and marches made business as usual impossible, for weeks, not one night.
- Consequences at the ballot box. Portland voters replaced board members in 1980; Oakland's did in 2022.
- A way for the board to back down. In 1982, the community set the terms of mediation, and the majority changed course without having to concede in public.