← PPS Rightsizing Guide

Full analysis

PPS's own communications playbook

NewAdded November 17: The superintendent's final recommendation, checked against PPS's own packet: a staffing target met without closures, savings PPS has already cut by 20% in a revised memo, a state seismic grant at risk at Marysville, and a size rule the west side doesn't follow


Contents

PPS's own communications playbook: what leaders are told to say#

In May 2026, PPS's chief of communications at the time, Candice Grose, wrote two documents for the rightsizing process: a 26-page Rightsizing Strategic Communications Plan and a 49-page Rightsizing Strategic Communications Playbook, both marked "Prepared by Candice Grose | Chief of Communications." In October, Memphis-Shelby County Schools named her its chief of communications, Tennessee Tribune and she posted both documents on her portfolio site as work samples; the files are titled "FINAL." Candice Grose: Case Studies As of November 10, the copies she posted no longer load, so the links below go to copies saved for this guide. Plan · Playbook The plan sets out the strategy, timeline, risks, and media approach. The playbook turns it into scripts: guardrails, "Avoid Language Like" lists, and tables of what to say, what people might say back, and the "counter narrative," written separately for central office leaders, board members, principals, and parent and community advocates. (Page numbers below are the ones printed on each page.)

It is built to move the public from "whether" to "how." For the fall, when the superintendent's proposal comes out, the plan's "Critical Focus" is to move the public from "Why are we doing this?" to "How were these recommendations developed?" Plan, p. 9 And it plans for the outcome in advance: "If recommendations are approved: Transition communications must already be operationalized." Plan, p. 3 The "Keep Reinforcing" list printed for every audience includes "Engagement is happening before recommendations are finalized" and "Community voice is part of the process." Playbook, pp. 15, 20, 26, 32 When a reporter asks what happens if the public opposes the recommendations, and pushes, "Will opposition change outcomes?", the scripted answer is that "engagement helps inform both recommendations and implementation planning." Plan, p. 20 It doesn't say yes. That is the shape the public conversation has taken: asked on the radio in October about calls to slow down, the superintendent called the no-closure option a delay, "C just delays the inevitable," and when asked for an example of feedback that had changed her thinking, said it was shaping her final recommendation but that she was "not yet ready" to share specifics. OPB: Think Out Loud, Oct 16

Organizing is a risk; success is measured in sentiment. The plan's risk table lists "political organizing/opposition" alongside "viral misinformation," "'closed-door decision' narratives," and "equity criticisms." Among the ways to manage them: "message discipline" and "social listening monitoring." Its measures of success are website traffic, "FAQ clicks," "time on page," the "accuracy of coverage, sentiment," "leader preparedness," meeting attendance, and video views. Plan, p. 12 None of them asks whether anything families said changed a recommendation. That is exactly the gap PPS's own auditors found in the last consolidation, where "perceptions of predetermined outcomes deeply undermined trust," and where they told the district that engagement must be "genuinely influential, not reactive to pre-developed plans" (see "PPS's own audit"). In fairness, a risk table is a list of reputational risks to the district; it isn't a plan to suppress anyone.

Board members get the same script as staff. The plan's fourth objective is that board members, the cabinet, principals, and school leaders all operate "from the same strategic message architecture," and "Board talking points" are among its first deliverables. Plan, pp. 3, 9 The playbook's Board Member Talking Guide describes their role as to "reinforce trust, maintain confidence in governance, demonstrate thoughtful stewardship," and to "maintain message discipline." Playbook, p. 19 Its "hallway diplomacy" table scripts what to say in a grocery store, and when a director is "asked to 'pick a side' publicly": "My responsibility is ensuring the process remains thoughtful, transparent, and student-centered." Playbook, p. 24 The board is supposed to oversee the superintendent, and on December 15 it will judge her recommendation. A script written by her staff casts the people who will decide the question as the ones reassuring the public about it. In fairness, directors are free to ignore it, and several have pressed staff hard in public (see "The equity case, checked"). We don't know which directors received the playbook or how they use it.

Parents are recruited as messengers. The Parent & Community Advocate Talking Guide opens by noting that families trust "other parents, community leaders, faith leaders, alumni, culturally specific organizations, and neighborhood advocates before they trust institutions." It says advocates aren't district spokespeople, then hands them the district's lines. Its guardrails tell them not to "predict school outcomes" or "share leaked or unofficial materials," and to avoid saying "The district already made up their mind." When a parent says "This is fake engagement," the scripted reply is that "community feedback is still part of the process before recommendations are finalized." Playbook, pp. 31–33, 36 This is the district-level version of the "This, Not That!" toolkit PPS gave its Village Table parent representatives (see "The same script, city to city").

Its own board script concedes the deficit remains. The playbook's core narrative says rightsizing "sustains and strengthens opportunities over time so resources are not stretched too thin across the system." Playbook, p. 4 But when someone tells a board member "This is just about money," the scripted answer ends: "Even after rightsizing, the district will still face a structural deficit." Playbook, p. 21 That matches the record: the superintendent's planning estimate of what closures save, $11–14 million, is a sixth to a fifth of the $65 million gap (see "What the research and other cities show").

It defines "well-resourced" by staffing. Leaders have defined it by size. The plan's glossary defines a well-resourced school as "a school with strong academic programs, supports, staffing, and opportunities for students," and its scripted answer to a reporter adds "stable staffing." Plan, pp. 13, 20 The playbook is candid about why the phrase was chosen: it "reframes the conversation from loss to access" and "lowers defensiveness." Playbook, p. 6 But the superintendent told OPB that "when we say well resourced, we're saying that we're getting to a size of 360," and the district's headline equity figure counts students in schools above a size line, not staffing (see "What the superintendent told Irvington families"). By the district's own definition, the staffing plan is what would make a school well-resourced, and it hasn't been published.

It never mentions the state. Neither document mentions Salem, the Legislature, the governor, the State School Fund, or the Education Stability Fund. The scripted budget statement begins, "Like many districts across the country, Portland Public Schools is navigating enrollment changes and rising operational costs." Plan, p. 22 Its answer to "Why not wait?" is that "waiting can create greater instability later." Playbook, p. 22 Yet PPS, its board, and its teachers' union have all asked the state to release its school reserve fund. KATU The district's own message strategy leaves out the funding fight it is in, and the playbook has no answer for the ask at the center of this guide: pause until Salem acts (see "What we're asking for").

Openness, then message control. At the March 31 work session, the superintendent told the board: "We've committed to a transparent public deliberation that means that our internal considerations will be shared openly." PPS Board of Education meetings (March 31, 2026 work session) Six weeks later, the playbook told central office leaders not to "share draft documents, maps, or internal conversations." Playbook, p. 15 In fairness, telling staff not to leak drafts protects families from rumors, and the plan praises launching the website early because it "reduces the appearance of secrecy." Plan, p. 24 But some of the internal considerations that would let families check the plan, like a seat count for every building, still aren't public; the 62-page technical methodology PPS posted on November 5 describes its capacity tables without publishing them. PPS: K–8 Scenario Modeling Technical Documentation (See "What PPS has, and hasn't, made public".)

How to use it. When you hear "Community voice is part of the process," ask the question the plan never measures: what in the recommendation changed because of it? Ask your board member whether they received district talking points on rightsizing, and to answer your questions in their own words. And if you file a public-records request, the plan names documents worth asking for: the board talking points, the internal leader toolkit, the stakeholder-specific toolkits, and any social listening reports. Plan, pp. 9, 12