← PPS Rightsizing Guide

Full analysis

The final recommendation, checked

NewAdded November 17: The superintendent's final recommendation, checked against PPS's own packet: a staffing target met without closures, savings PPS has already cut by 20% in a revised memo, a state seismic grant at risk at Marysville, and a size rule the west side doesn't follow


Contents

The final recommendation, checked against PPS's own numbersNew#

The superintendent's recommendation is the plan the board will actually vote on. It arrived on November 12 as a 62-page memo with 18 attachments: closure reports for each school, impact summaries for every school that changes, a staffing model, a savings table, sample bus routes, and an equity impact statement. PPS: Superintendent's recommendation and attachments, Nov 17 board meeting This is the most PPS has published, and it's enough to check the plan. Page numbers below refer to the memo unless noted.

What it does. Ten elementary schools close, phased over two years:

Fall 2027 Students go to Fall 2028 Students go to
Beach Chief Joseph (Spanish immersion to César Chávez) Lewis Duniway
Buckman Abernethy and Sunnyside (arts program ends) Marysville Arleta and Kelly
Creston Atkinson (Deaf and Hard of Hearing program to Glencoe) Rose City Park Scott (Vietnamese immersion to Vestal)
Irvington Beverly Cleary (in the Irvington building for 2027-28) Woodmere Whitman
Peninsula Rosa Parks
Sabin King

The East Sylvan building also closes, with Odyssey moving to Forest Park. Seven K-8 schools become K-5 schools, Spanish immersion shrinks from nine elementary sites to four, and Mandarin from three to two. Sellwood Middle, James John, Maplewood, and Stephenson come off the list. Five of the 10 closing schools are Title I schools: Beach, Buckman, Peninsula, Marysville, and Woodmere. PPS: Title I schools, 2026-27 PPS says 5,641 K-8 students, 19%, would change schools or programs. (pp. 1–2, 22–41, 46)

1. Closing schools doesn't save school jobs

This is the number that matters most, and it's in a section titled "Methodology & Important Caveats." To compare the plan with doing nothing, PPS applied the same cutting rules to both, counting positions "before add-backs and reinvestments are applied." Without closures, the model cuts 277.5 school positions; with them, 308.5. "The stated target is 223 FTE to address our projected $65 million budget deficit. Both items are over reduced to allow for the opportunity for some reinvestment." (p. 50)

Read that carefully: PPS's own model reaches its staffing target without closing a school. Without closures, it cuts 54.5 more positions than the target, leaving room to add some back. Closures aren't what gets PPS to its number. With them, the model cuts 31 more positions before add-backs. PPS says the closures free about 22 positions to reinvest, 15 to 20 of them in schools taking in students, and move 8.5 to Title I elementary schools that receive students. It doesn't publish the net for either version after add-backs. (pp. 50–51) In the school-by-school table, the difference is 41.5 positions out of about 2,200. PPS says it didn't change class-size ratios in either version; its weighted average class size is 27.1 students without closures and 27.4 with them, before reinvestments. (pp. 51–54) The memo credits the closures with "about 75 FTE in programmatic efficiencies," (p. 50) a figure its own tables don't reconcile with a 31-position difference.

Which positions these are. The model counts staff assigned to school buildings. It leaves out special education, multilingual services, Title I, and Measure 98. (p. 50) The memo never breaks the cuts down by job: how many are classroom teachers; arts, PE, and library teachers; counselors; assistants; or administrators. It does say the closures' cuts include 10.5 principal and administrative assistant positions, with the rest coming from "programmatic efficiencies." With class-size ratios unchanged, merging schools most likely means fewer homeroom classes and fewer specialists split across buildings: fewer teaching positions for about the same number of students. PPS describes it as a way "to protect core classroom instruction." (pp. 50–51) The board should see the job-by-job numbers before it votes. And these are only part of the cuts. The $65 million is split between $41.9 million from schools and districtwide student supports and $23.1 million from central office and building operations, with "central office budget decisions" coming first. PPS: Financial Update, Nov 17 The packet gives no districtwide count of positions. On November 2, the superintendent said up to 450 could be cut. KPTV, Nov 2 For teachers at closing schools, the contract adds a second cut: they compete by seniority for whatever positions remain, and those who don't get one are "unassigned" (see "What it means for teachers and staff").

The closure savings themselves come from school jobs. Each closure report says the savings include "administrative, custodial, and office staffing" at the closing school. PPS: School Closure Reports (Attachment C) The board has been told the choice is closures or deeper cuts to schools. By PPS's own model, the cuts to schools happen either way; closing buildings doesn't spare them.

Administration first, as the Governor said. At her post-election press conference on November 6, Gov. Tina Kotek said the district "needs to do everything they possibly can to cut administrative costs and other things before they talk about closing schools," and should be "reducing all other costs before they start impacting the student experience." Gov. Tina Kotek: post-election press conference, Nov 6 (video) · KATU PPS's plan runs the other way. Its budget targets take $41.9 million from schools and districtwide student supports and $9.6 million from the central office, with $13.5 million from building operations. PPS says "Central Office budget decisions come first," but its budget recommendations aren't due to the board until January 12, 2027, four weeks after the closure vote. PPS: Financial Update, Nov 17 The board is being asked to close schools before it has seen what PPS will cut from its own offices.

2. The savings are small, the table doesn't add up, and none of it goes to the deficit

The memo projects "net recurring savings" of "about $10.2 million across both years," and says "about $7.1 million remains to reinvest in receiving schools, transportation and transition supports." (p. 2) Four days after releasing the memo, on November 17, the day the superintendent presented it to the board, PPS posted a revised version with a corrected savings table: $5,654,819 left to reinvest, 20% less than the first version. The summary on page 2 wasn't updated and still says $7.1 million. PPS: Superintendent's recommendation, revised Nov 17 (v1.1) (pp. 2, 49–50, and change log) These are the superintendent's estimates, and even taken at face value, $5.65 million is 8.7% of the $65 million gap. It's also earmarked: the memo reserves it for receiving schools and buses, not the deficit.

The table behind those figures had problems, and PPS has fixed only some of them. (pp. 49–50)

  • The first version left out costs it listed. The original table counted $1.02 million to move programs and reconfigure grades, then didn't subtract it from "remaining to reinvest." It didn't subtract its own 5% contingency ($354,464) either, and a formula error dropped $60,000 from year 2. The revised table fixes all three. Its change log says the moving costs "are now included in the remaining to reinvest" and the contingency is now subtracted. (Revised memo, pp. 49–50, change log) The board got a savings figure $1.4 million too high, and the memo's summary still carries it.
  • The bus costs are somewhere else. The table counts $335,000 in net transportation costs. The memo's transportation section says the plan raises bus routes from 122 to 153, "approximately $2.7 million" a year, (p. 55) · PPS: Sample Transportation Routes (Attachment O) and separately estimates the dual-language bus hubs at "a net annual transportation cost increase of $3 million." (p. 55) The revision didn't touch this. PPS hasn't said whether the table includes either figure. If it doesn't, about $3.0 million is left, roughly 4.5% of the gap. (Our arithmetic on PPS's revised table.)
  • The bus numbers point both ways. For nine of the 10 schools, the closure report and the savings table disagree about whether busing costs or saves money. For Sabin, the report says busing costs nothing because "the number of buses remains the same"; the table books a $25,716 cost. Peninsula's report says Rosa Parks goes "from zero to four buses" at "an additional annual cost of approximately $170,000"; the table books it as a $169,511 saving. PPS: School Closure Reports (Attachment C)
  • Some reports carry another school's numbers. Beach's "cost of school operations" and Rose City Park's "projected overall savings" are both Sabin's figures. None of the reports is signed.

And the bigger driver of the deficit is somewhere else entirely. The board's own 2027 legislative agenda says "approximately two-thirds of the projected $65 million shortfall is directly driven by rising PERS rates," and asks the governor and Legislature "to allocate $500 million from the Education Stability Fund to buy down PERS rates for school districts statewide." PPS Board of Education: 2027 Legislative Agenda That's the same fund families are asking the state to release (see "What we're asking for"). The board and the families opposing this plan want the same money. They disagree about whether to close schools before Salem answers.

3. The plan breaks its own rules

It closes a school that meets PPS's own size line. Rose City Park's closure report projects 391 students next year and 370 by 2031-32, and says so plainly: enrollment "remains above the district's 360 student threshold and does not, on its own, indicate that the school would be unable to maintain stable staffing, programming, or essential student supports." Meanwhile, Scott, which would take its students, drops to 323 in 2027-28 when its Spanish immersion program leaves, below the line. The plan empties one school, then closes a school that meets the standard to refill it. PPS: School Closure Reports (Attachment C) · PPS: School Impact Summaries (Attachment D)

It keeps open schools smaller than ones it closes. The memo lists James John, Maplewood, Sitton, and Sunrise at "less than 260 students" in 2031-32, with Stephenson "just above at 261," and keeps all five open to "monitor closely." (pp. 42–43) Sitton is projected at 225. Irvington, which closes, is projected at 223. Stephenson stays open because its enrollment "has leveled out," with a rule: "if it declines two years in a row a deeper review will be started." (p. 26) No closing school was offered that rule. Irvington enrolled 259 students both last fall and this fall, more than Portland State forecast four years running. PPS: October 1 enrollment, 2026-27

On the west side, the line doesn't apply at all. Of the 10 neighborhood elementary schools in the Lincoln and Ida B. Wells clusters, Portland State projects eight under 360 students in 2031-32. The plan closes none of them and changes none of their numbers. PSU forecast, Table 5.5

West-side elementary 2031-32 Under 360?
Ainsworth 557 no
Bridlemile 408 no
Markham 347 yes
Chapman 333 yes
Capitol Hill 311 yes
Rieke 311 yes
Hayhurst 266 yes
Stephenson 261 yes
Forest Park 258 yes
Maplewood 247 yes

That's the memo's own figure: 20% of west-side elementary schools at PPS's size line after the plan, the lowest of any region. (p. 47) Skyline K-8 is projected at 177 and Gray Middle at 368, both under the 500 line. Every west-side school under the line is projected smaller than Rose City Park (370), which closes, and four of them (Hayhurst, Stephenson, Forest Park, and Maplewood) are smaller than Beach (287) and Marysville (312), which also close.

This isn't an argument for closing west-side schools. It's that PPS sells the 360 line as the reason for the plan, then says in the same memo that its criteria "were weighed against one another rather than applied as a fixed ranking, and the balance struck differs from one part of the city to another." (p. 14) Where the line bends, the west side gets monitoring now and "a regional boundary review process, starting on the west side," later. (p. 1) The memo's only nod toward a reason is families' concern about the west side's topography, traffic, and limited transit, (pp. 13–14) a real constraint, but not the size rule the plan is built on. Wait, monitor, and study first is exactly what families across the city are asking for. PPS is already doing it in one region.

It closes bigger buildings to fill smaller ones. In seven of the 10 closures, the closing building holds more students than the school taking them in: Beach (607) into Chief Joseph (444), Buckman (633) into Sunnyside (492) and Abernethy (449), Creston (558) into Atkinson (519), Irvington (618) into Beverly Cleary (531), Peninsula (539) into Rosa Parks (499), Sabin (621) into King (584), and Woodmere (465) into Whitman (416). Most receiving schools end up at 91% to 99% of capacity. Whitman ends up at 107%, and its report says it "will likely need to re-evaluate the three classrooms dedicated to early childhood," meaning the PPS Pre-K at a Title I school. Every receiving school's impact summary still marks classroom capacity "Readiness: Yes." PPS: School Closure Reports (Attachment C) · PPS: School Impact Summaries (Attachment D) That leaves no room if enrollment recovers, the reason PPS gave for keeping Sellwood Middle open: high school modernizations finishing in 2029 "may bring students back into PPS." (p. 25)

It leans on building condition after saying it wouldn't. PPS's measures for the plan say building condition "will not be the primary driver of scenario selection." PPS: Rightsizing Key Performance Indicators (Attachment P) The impact summaries for Beach, Buckman, and Rose City Park lead with "the building needs major repairs." Sabin and Peninsula, two of the closing buildings, are rated in "Fair" condition, the best on the list.

It puts PPS at risk of defaulting on a state contract. In 2024, the state's Seismic Rehabilitation Grant Program, run by Business Oregon, awarded Marysville $2.5 million toward a $7 million seismic retrofit, finished in September 2026. The contract says "the Project must be used for its existing purposes" for 10 years after completion, through 2036. Marysville's own closure report says the same: the grant "requires that the building continue to be used for a public educational program or school until ten years after the project completion date." PPS: School Closure Reports (Attachment C) The plan closes it as a school in 2028, two years in. A Business Oregon spokesperson told Willamette Week that closing it early "has potential to be considered an event of default," and the contract's most severe remedy is repaying the grant in full. The state says that remedy isn't automatic and it would work with the district. PPS's answer was that grant compliance "would be one of the factors considered in determining preferred uses of district property." Willamette Week, Oct 16 The packet doesn't count that risk, or the $2.5 million, anywhere in the savings.

4. The equity statement argues against the plan

PPS's own equity impact statement is unusually candid. (pp. 46–48)

  • "Multilingual learners carry more of this change than any other group." 26.5% of them would move, against 19.0% of all K-8 students; 21.4% of students in poverty, 20.0% of students with IEPs, and 21.7% of students from historically underserved racial groups.
  • Students move out of 15 of PPS's 32 Title I schools (47%), against 18 of 50 other schools (36%).
  • "The families least represented in the community feedback are the families most affected by the largest program change in the package. Multilingual families are about one in eight students and about one in 50 survey respondents." The board's own Racial Educational Equity Policy commits PPS to treat families of color, "including those whose first language may not be English," as "essential partners in … PPS decision-making." PPS: Policy 2.10.010-P
  • "The Ida B. Wells/Lincoln region contributes no closures and has the fewest schools at sustainable enrollment levels." On the west side, 20% of elementary schools reach PPS's size line, and none closes.

Then it sets a condition: "The analysis supports moving forward on the condition that the commitments are funded, owned and monitored rather than described. Without those commitments, this is an enrollment plan with an equity result." The impact summaries show what has been funded. For SUN community schools, racial-equity partners, and child care, they say continuation "will depend on County, PPS and City budget processes" or "will be dependent on the PPS budget process." PPS: School Impact Summaries (Attachment D) By the statement's own test, this is an enrollment plan.

PPS also attached the equity audit of its last consolidation, and summarized it as having "generally improved enrollment balance." (p. 10) The same audit found that projections overestimated enrollment at 12 of the 20 schools involved, that 39% of staff of color at those schools left them in the first year, and that only 3% of staff trust PPS to handle rightsizing fairly. Before any final decision, it says, PPS should be able to show "whether affected students will move to stronger and better-resourced schools, whether receiving schools are ready, what transition supports will be funded," and "how much the district realistically expects to save." PPS: SEGC Equity Audit Evaluation (Attachment E) This packet doesn't show any of those.

5. The numbers that will decide it arrive after the vote

  • The forecast. PPS's staffing projections "will be updated following the release of Portland State University's revised enrollment forecasts in January." (p. 50)
  • The state budget. The Governor's recommended budget comes in early December; the Legislature's appropriations by the end of June. PPS: Financial Update, Nov 17
  • The transition plan. The implementation framework "will be shared with the community in December." PPS: School Impact Summaries (Attachment D)
  • Irvington's year as a temporary site. "If in-process feasibility assessments confirm," with transportation costs "assessed separately." PPS: School Closure Reports (Attachment C)

Nothing in board policy requires a December 15 vote. The boundary policy sets an "intention that all changes be approved no later than January of the calendar year for the following school year." PPS: Policy 4.10.045-P For fall 2027, that's the end of January, after the new forecast and the Governor's budget. For the fall 2028 closures, it's January 2028.

The closure policy, meanwhile, lets the board close a school "only upon a recommendation by the Superintendent accompanied by a School Closure Report which shall contain a full and adequate analysis." The first item it requires is "actual cost per student." PPS: Policy 6.10.030-P The reports give a projected cost instead, contradict the savings table on busing, and answer the policy's equity question with nearly the same paragraph for all 10 schools.

Questions this raises for the board:

  • PPS's model reaches its target of 223 school positions without closing a school, and closures add 31 more before reinvestment. After add-backs, what is the net difference, and how many of those positions are classroom teachers?
  • What administrative and central-office cuts will PPS make, and why won't the board see them before it votes to close schools?
  • How do the 223 to 308.5 school positions break down by job (classroom teachers, specialists, counselors, assistants, administrators), and how many positions will be cut districtwide, central office included?
  • Is the $2.7 million in added bus routes counted in the savings table? If not, what is the net?
  • Which closure does each first-year reconfiguration depend on?
  • Why does Sitton, projected at 225, stay open to be monitored while Irvington, projected at 223, closes?
  • Eight of 10 west-side elementary schools are projected under 360 and none closes, with a boundary review promised later. Why does the rest of the city get closures instead of the same review?
  • Has PPS asked Business Oregon whether closing Marysville in 2028 puts it in default, and could it have to repay the $2.5 million grant?
  • The board has asked Salem for $500 million in pension relief. Why vote before Salem answers?