← PPS Rightsizing Guide

Full analysis

Where students land

NewAdded November 17: The superintendent's final recommendation, checked against PPS's own packet: a staffing target met without closures, savings PPS has already cut by 20% in a revised memo, a state seismic grant at risk at Marysville, and a size rule the west side doesn't follow


Contents

Where students land: the schools that would receive them#

Why this matters. Two arguments for the plan turn on where students end up. The national research says closures help only when displaced students land in a clearly better school (see "What the research and other cities show"). And board members backing the plan argue that it moves the district's focal students (students of color, students in poverty, students with disabilities, multilingual learners) into "sustainable" schools that can serve them better. PPS: Oct 20 board meeting Both claims can be checked against the state's own data, so we checked them.

How we checked. For each of the 14 closing schools, we compared its 2025-26 state test results with those of the main school receiving its students, for all students and for each focal group the state reports. ODE: Assessment Group Reports We used grades 3–5 (grades 6–8 for Sellwood Middle and its receiving schools), so K-8 receiving schools like Beverly Cleary and King are compared on the same grades. Spending per student comes from the state's school-level spending report for 2024-25. ODE: School Level Expenditure Report When we first checked, no district document listed which school receives which closing school's students, so the pairings came from Director Stephanie Engelsman's list at the October 20 board meeting, PPS: Oct 20 board meeting the special-education parent group SEPTSA's report, SEPTSA and the district's own scenario summary for the dual-language moves. PPS: district-wide scenarios The figures behind every chart are in the table under it.

Reading, all students: closing school vs. the school receiving its students

Percent of students meeting the state standard, 2025-26, grades 3–5 (grades 6–8 for Sellwood). Each closing school is paired with its main receiving school.

Closing schoolSchool receiving its students

Buckman→ Abernethy
Marysville→ Arleta
Irvington→ Beverly Cleary
Beach→ Chief Joseph
James John→ Sitton
Lewis→ Duniway
Woodmere→ Whitman
Maplewood→ Hayhurst
Stephenson→ Markham
Sabin→ King
Sellwood→ Hosford
Creston→ Atkinson
Rose City Park→ Scott
Peninsula→ Rosa Parks
Show as a table
Closing schoolResultReceiving schoolResult
Buckman52%Abernethy82%
Marysville32%Arleta61%
Irvington68%Beverly Cleary80%
Beach56%Chief Joseph66%
James John35%Sitton44%
Lewis71%Duniway76%
Woodmere29%Whitman33%
Maplewood64%Hayhurst67%
Stephenson74%Markham65%
Sabin58%King48%
Sellwood78%Hosford66%
Creston69%Atkinson57%
Rose City Park56%Scott39%
Peninsula44%Rosa Parks15%

On the measure the research uses, it's a coin flip. In reading, eight closing schools send students to a higher-scoring school, led by Buckman (52% to Abernethy's 82%), Marysville (32% to Arleta's 61%), and Irvington (68% to Beverly Cleary's 80%). Six send them to a lower-scoring one, led by Peninsula (44% to Rosa Parks' 15%), Rose City Park (56% to Scott's 39%), and Sellwood (78% to Hosford's 66%, and 37% at Brentwood for its other half). Math tips the other way: six higher, seven lower, one about even.

Math, all students: closing school vs. the school receiving its students

Percent of students meeting the state standard, 2025-26, grades 3–5 (grades 6–8 for Sellwood). Each closing school is paired with its main receiving school.

Closing schoolSchool receiving its students

Marysville→ Arleta
Buckman→ Abernethy
Irvington→ Beverly Cleary
Beach→ Chief Joseph
Lewis→ Duniway
James John→ Sitton
Woodmere→ Whitman
Sabin→ King
Maplewood→ Hayhurst
Creston→ Atkinson
Stephenson→ Markham
Sellwood→ Hosford
Rose City Park→ Scott
Peninsula→ Rosa Parks
Show as a table
Closing schoolResultReceiving schoolResult
Marysville24%Arleta56%
Buckman40%Abernethy72%
Irvington61%Beverly Cleary80%
Beach48%Chief Joseph61%
Lewis64%Duniway75%
James John27%Sitton37%
Woodmere28%Whitman26%
Sabin48%King44%
Maplewood65%Hayhurst60%
Creston65%Atkinson55%
Stephenson74%Markham60%
Sellwood71%Hosford55%
Rose City Park54%Scott37%
Peninsula40%Rosa Parks12%

The biggest drops land in North Portland and in the dual-language programs. Peninsula's students move from 44% to 15% in reading and from 40% to 12% in math. Sabin's students move to King, 58% to 48% in reading. And the Spanish-immersion students from Beach (56%) and James John (35%) move to César Chávez, where 20% of third-to-fifth graders meet the reading standard. These are the families the district's equity case is built around.

Students with disabilities: about half land lower, and the drops are steep. Where the state reports their results at both schools, students with disabilities move to a lower-scoring setting in 4 of 9 cases in reading and 5 of 9 in math. The largest drops: Stephenson (57% to Markham's 20% in reading), Sellwood (53% to Hosford's 27%), and Rose City Park (44% to Scott's 29%). The two clear gains are Maplewood (18% to Hayhurst's 59%) and James John (20% to Sitton's 33%). This matches what the special-education parent group found from a different direction: receiving schools that would absorb more students with disabilities without the space or staff to match. SEPTSA

Reading, students with disabilities: closing school vs. the school receiving its students

Percent of students meeting the state standard, 2025-26, grades 3–5 (grades 6–8 for Sellwood). Each closing school is paired with its main receiving school.

Closing schoolSchool receiving its students

Maplewood→ Hayhurst
James John→ Sitton
Marysville→ Arleta
Creston→ Atkinson
Sabin→ King
Irvington→ Beverly Cleary
Rose City Park→ Scott
Sellwood→ Hosford
Stephenson→ Markham

Not shown, because the state hides results for fewer than 10 students tested: Buckman, Lewis, Beach, Woodmere, Peninsula.

Show as a table
Closing schoolResultReceiving schoolResult
Maplewood18%Hayhurst59%
James John20%Sitton33%
Marysville38%Arleta42%
Creston43%Atkinson46%
Sabin26%King27%
Irvington54%Beverly Cleary50%
Rose City Park44%Scott29%
Sellwood53%Hosford27%
Stephenson57%Markham20%

The plan also closes three of the schools PPS built for them. Since 2023, PPS has been turning neighborhood schools into "Inclusive School Communities," where students with disabilities are taught in their own neighborhood school instead of in a separate program at another school; there are now eight. PPS: Inclusive School Communities Both scenarios close three of them: Marysville, James John, and Peninsula. That's more than a third of the program, against fewer than one in four of the district's elementary and K-8 schools (13 of 56). PPS: Enrollment of Underserved Groups, Oct 1, 2025 PPS's own progress report on the model, from this year, is encouraging: its students attended school better than a comparison group on every measure, and 24.2% of its autistic students met reading expectations, against 10.7% in the comparison group. PPS: Inclusive Schools Progress Report 2025-26 The inclusive schools that remain would take on much of the load: SEPTSA estimates they would average about 470 students, up from 307 today, with about 123 students on IEPs each, up from 73. SEPTSA

In fairness, PPS describes these as early, modest results, its math results showed no clear difference, and closing a building doesn't end the model: Peninsula's students would move to Rosa Parks and James John's to Sitton, both inclusive schools, and PPS says Marysville and Arleta would unite as one inclusive school. PPS family guides The question is whether those schools get the staff to absorb them. After the last consolidation, staff at the affected schools said they didn't (see PPS's own audit of the last consolidation).

Students in poverty: mixed, and here the plan's defenders have a point. Comparing students in poverty with students in poverty removes much of the difference that comes from who attends each school. On that measure the picture is more even. At King, students in poverty outscore their peers at Sabin (19% vs. 7% in reading, 25% vs. 7% in math), and at Sitton they outscore their peers at James John (32% vs. 19%). But Sellwood's students in poverty move from 51% to 30% at Hosford, Rose City Park's from 26% to 17% at Scott, and Maplewood's from 50% to 22% at Hayhurst (only 10 of Maplewood's students in poverty were tested). Results for students in poverty are hidden at half the pairs.

Black students: the data can't show what the plan's defenders claim. The state hides results for any grade with fewer than 10 students tested. At every one of the 14 closing schools, that hides Black students' results, in both subjects. So there is no public test data showing how Black students at the closing schools are doing, or whether moving them would help. What the data does show is the receiving schools. Where Black students' results are reported there, most are below the district average for Black students (20% in reading, grades 3–5): King 15%, Rosa Parks 15%, Kelly 10%, and Scott 10%, with Brentwood at 10% in grades 6–8 (district average 19%). Sitton (31%) and Markham (42%) are above it. These groups are small, between 10 and 49 students tested, so treat any single school's number with caution. But Peninsula's and Sabin's students, about 60 Black students between them, go to Rosa Parks and King, two of the schools where Black students currently score below the district's Black-student average. ODE: Assessment Group Reports

How many Black students are involved. PPS's own enrollment count shows 251 Black students at the 14 closing schools this year, 5.9% of their students, somewhat below the district's share (8.3%). PPS: Enrollment of Underserved Groups, Oct 1, 2025 Where they would go:

Closing school Black students Main receiving school Black students
Marysville 37 (12.1%) Arleta 5 (2.2%)
Peninsula 32 (13.4%) Rosa Parks 57 (35.6%)
Beach 32 (11.1%) Chief Joseph* 13 (5.4%)
James John 28 (7.7%) Sitton* 40 (11.6%)
Sabin 28 (10.4%) King 100 (31.3%)
Irvington 23 (8.9%) Beverly Cleary 11 (2.3%)
Woodmere 23 (10.1%) Whitman 22 (11.3%)
Buckman 13 (4.6%) Abernethy 3 (1.1%)
Rose City Park 9 (2.2%) Scott 49 (10.3%)
Stephenson 8 (2.8%) Markham 58 (17.1%)
Maplewood 5 (1.7%) Hayhurst 17 (5.9%)
Creston 5 (2.3%) Atkinson 4 (1.1%)
Lewis 4 (1.5%) Duniway none reported
Sellwood 4 (0.7%) Hosford / Brentwood 14 (2.7%) / 58 (13.0%)

* Spanish-immersion students go to César Chávez, which enrolls 52 Black students (11.7%). Counts are as of October 1, 2025, and include every grade, not just the tested ones.

Spending per student: closing school vs. the school receiving its students

Total spending per student, 2024-25, all funding sources (Oregon Department of Education).

Closing schoolSchool receiving its students

Peninsula→ Rosa Parks
Sabin→ King
Rose City Park→ Scott
Stephenson→ Markham
James John→ Sitton
Sellwood→ Hosford
Woodmere→ Whitman
Buckman→ Abernethy
Beach→ Chief Joseph
Lewis→ Duniway
Irvington→ Beverly Cleary
Marysville→ Arleta
Creston→ Atkinson
Maplewood→ Hayhurst
Show as a table
Closing schoolResultReceiving schoolResult
Peninsula$26.6kRosa Parks$33.3k
Sabin$23.8kKing$26.2k
Rose City Park$23.6kScott$25.6k
Stephenson$22.1kMarkham$23.9k
James John$25.6kSitton$26.8k
Sellwood$21.4kHosford$21.4k
Woodmere$28.5kWhitman$28.3k
Buckman$24.0kAbernethy$23.2k
Beach$25.3kChief Joseph$23.9k
Lewis$23.2kDuniway$21.8k
Irvington$23.9kBeverly Cleary$21.6k
Marysville$27.5kArleta$25.1k
Creston$27.0kAtkinson$23.3k
Maplewood$22.8kHayhurst$18.9k

Spending per student follows the receiving school, not the merger. Students moving into high-poverty schools land where spending per student is already higher, mostly because of federal and equity-formula money: Peninsula's students go from $26.6k to $33.3k at Rosa Parks, and Sabin's from $23.8k to $26.2k at King. Students moving into larger, lower-poverty schools land where it's lower: Irvington's go from $23.9k to $21.6k at Beverly Cleary, and Lewis's from $23.2k to $21.8k at Duniway. That second pattern is the efficiency PPS is after: fixed costs spread over more students. Either way, closing a building doesn't add money per student; it moves students into whatever the receiving school already spends. Spending also measures cost, not services. Whether merged schools actually get more teachers, specialists, or smaller classes depends on the staffing plan the superintendent has promised with her November 17 recommendation. ODE: School Level Expenditure Report

In fairness, doing nothing isn't a neutral option either: under the status quo, more schools shrink below the size PPS says it needs to staff a full program, and the district projects that only 48% of students would be in a "sustainable" school. PPS: district-wide scenarios But "sustainable" counts students, not outcomes. On the outcome the research says matters, this plan moves about as many students down as up, and the moves that go down fall hardest on North Portland, on dual-language families, and on students with disabilities.

Questions this raises for the board:

  • Where a closing school's students split among several schools, what share goes to each? PPS has published the shares for only a few.
  • For each receiving school, what is the plan to serve students moving in from a higher-scoring school, and students with disabilities in particular?
  • Will the staffing plan show, school by school, whether merged schools get more staff per student than the schools closing?